Placeholder Image

字幕表 動画を再生する

  • Trophy hunting is good?

  • What are you talking about?

  • Trophy hunting is barbaric.

  • I am against it.

  • You can tell by my tote bag.

  • Look, I don't like it any more than you do.

  • I'm an animal lover, too, see?

  • This argument is really counterintuitive and, frankly,

  • kind of difficult to accept,

  • but I ask that you keep an open mind and hear me out,

  • because the evidence suggests that, in specific situations,

  • trophy hunting can really help endangered animals.

  • But how?

  • How can killing animals help animals?

  • Come here, I'll show ya.

  • (Adam) ...as read by Adam Conover.

  • Whoa! I'm an ostrich!

  • I am a frog man, and in Africa,

  • animals like these are in desperate straits.

  • Oh, my God. Can I finally talk to animals?

  • Do... you... love me?

  • Hey, no touching!

  • There are only 5,000 of us left alive, you know.

  • Ugh, I drink 50 gallons of water a day,

  • and I'm not as thirsty as this girl.

  • And the real threat to these animals

  • isn't trophy hunters.

  • 'Sup? Ahem!

  • I'm a rich bro

  • who takes occasional hunting trips to Africa.

  • What can I say?

  • Kablammin' rare mammals makes me feel like a man.

  • (gunshot)

  • Meant to do that.

  • Judge this dweeb all you want,

  • but he's not why these animals are at risk of dying out.

  • The real threats are loss of habitat and poaching.

  • We're a criminal cartel

  • that systematically kills thousands of animals a year.

  • We cut off the horns and tusks

  • and sell them to foreign businessmen.

  • I shot Babar right through the heart, for money.

  • (laughing maniacally)

  • Poachers are organized, they're ruthless,

  • and they are decimating animal populations.

  • In some countries, rhino horn is believed

  • to cure cancer and even hangovers,

  • and sells for $28,000 a pound.

  • That's more than gold or cocaine.

  • (sniffs) Ahh.

  • Uck! That's awful!

  • Why don't the locals stop them?

  • Well, they're kinda busy, you know, living their lives.

  • Yeah, I got a family to feed.

  • Why should I waste time protecting a frickin' lion?

  • In his defense, I do eat his livestock on the regs.

  • Heck, sometimes I attack adults and children.

  • (gulp)

  • Hey!

  • And just as harmful to animal populations

  • is the habitat loss caused by farming.

  • These animals are literally running out of places to live.

  • So, some African nations came up with a plan.

  • They took advantage of the existing demand

  • for trophy hunting...

  • I would like to bazooka one rhinoceros, please.

  • ...and used it to fund animal conservation.

  • Fine. There's an aggressive male who's too old to breed,

  • has attacked three people, and killed five other rhinos.

  • He's basically an ass(bleep).

  • You can shoot him for... $350,000.

  • Deal! This is what I choose to spend my money on

  • for some reason.

  • Here's your receipt and your

  • "I'm a Rich Jerk Who Shoots Rhinos" tote bag.

  • What the hell? He's gonna kill a rhino.

  • Yes, but we're going to use that money

  • to save more rhinos.

  • Say whaaaaat?!

  • Yeah, in Namibia, revenue from trophy hunting

  • is the main way they fund new wildlife conservancies.

  • And in South Africa, a portion of the proceeds

  • from trophy hunting is given directly

  • to local land owners, and that incentivizes them

  • to give the rhinos land to live on

  • and to protect them from poachers.

  • Hey! Stay away from those rhinos!

  • They're worth more alive than dead!

  • Breed, my little moneybags, breed.

  • But he's keeping them alive so they can be hunted!

  • Absolutely true, but still, this system works.

  • One-third of all white rhinos in South Africa

  • now live on private land,

  • and their population has gone from just 100

  • to more than 18,000.

  • I'm so confused!

  • You know ostriches don't really do that, right?

  • (muffled) I don't care!

  • It feels good.

  • Veronica, I understand that this is hard to believe.

  • I had a tough time with it, too.

  • But then I talked to Rosie Cooney,

  • the chair of the Sustainable Use and Livelihood Specialist Group

  • of the International Union for the Conservation of Nature.

  • Whew! Glad I got through that whole title.

  • It's true, Veronica.

  • Trophy hunting can be a valuable part of conservation efforts,

  • even if you find hunting distasteful.

  • It's not the hunters running these programs.

  • It's the government agencies

  • or sometimes even conservation groups themselves.

  • The hunters' motives don't really matter.

  • The money they generate

  • can really help the animals who need it.

  • (Veronica) But how do I know the money

  • is going to the right place?

  • Well, that's a good question.

  • Like any program where there's a lot of corruption

  • or where things are badly managed,

  • these programs don't work well at all.

  • But that doesn't change the fact that when they are well-managed,

  • these programs can be a huge help for wildlife conservation.

  • In Namibia, for example,

  • 100% of the hunting concession fees

  • go straight to the local communities.

  • It's been a huge success.

  • I don't know.

  • I still think that we should ban trophy hunting

  • and find another way to help these animals.

  • Sorry, but that's not a great idea.

  • Many countries are depending on this revenue to protect animals,

  • to pay the game guards, to buy the vehicles.

  • What happens if that money dries up?

  • It's very easy for us in the developed world

  • to judge how other countries should manage their animals,

  • but should it be our decision?

  • Or should it be up to the communities

  • who live with these animals every day?

  • Hunting is a really important source of conservation revenue,

  • even where you are, Veronica, in the U.S.

  • Hunting fees generate around $200 million a year,

  • which for many states is their primary source

  • of conservation funding.

  • If we banned all trophy hunting everywhere,

  • right now, it would do way more harm than good.

  • Bye, guys!

  • Yeah, thank you! Bye!

  • Oh, man. Fun way to travel.

  • (rifle cocks, gunshot)

  • Okay, stop!

  • I don't care how much good it does,

  • I hate that anyone would be allowed to kill an animal!

  • I just want to stop them from suffering.

  • Why is killing them the only solution?

  • I know it's hard.

  • We love these animals so much,

  • we can't imagine any benefit coming from their deaths.

  • It just seems wrong.

  • But you know what's worse than one animal

  • getting killed by a hunter?

  • Hundreds of thousands being wiped out by poaching

  • and loss of habitat.

  • The truth is, in some nations,

  • the regulated hunting of a few individuals

  • is helping to save entire species.

  • So, cute animals have to die... to live?

  • Well, I guess that's one way of putting it.

  • (ominous music)

  • (gasping and whimpering)

  • (shrieking)

  • I'm doing this for your own good.

Trophy hunting is good?

字幕と単語

ワンタップで英和辞典検索 単語をクリックすると、意味が表示されます

B1 中級

アダムはすべてを台無しにする - なぜトロフィーハンティングは動物にとって良いことができるのか (Adam Ruins Everything - Why Trophy Hunting Can Be Good for Animals)

  • 950 36
    林玟靜 に公開 2021 年 01 月 14 日
動画の中の単語