Placeholder Image

字幕表 動画を再生する

  • So, Oscar, you asked the question, "What are some of the easiest ways that you can prove

  • that the Earth is round?"

  • Because apparently, this is something that we're debating—I have no idea why.

  • That's a hard thing for me to even start talking about because there are so many proofs that

  • the Earth is round, it's difficult to know where to start.

  • And it's not okay to think that the Earth is flat.

  • This is not a viable argument.

  • I have friends who have been on the International Space Station, they have orbited the Earth

  • once every 90 minutes; I've had personal experience with people who have been up in space and

  • can see with their own eyes that the Earth is round.

  • And of course, we've taken all of these amazing pictures from space; they're so beautiful,

  • all those pictures of the Earth.

  • So I don't really know what's going on right now with this 'Earth is flat' thing, but I

  • will tell you that this is one of the things I really enjoyed teaching my own astronomy

  • class about because there are proofs all around you.

  • It is not difficult to know that the Earth is round.

  • In fact, people have known of this for way more than 2,000 years.

  • The ancient Greeks actually had a number of really elegant, wonderful proofs that the

  • earth was a sphere.

  • So let's start from the simple to the slightly more complicated.

  • One of the things you can see yourself, with a pair of binoculars, is if you actually go

  • out to a lake and there are boats on that lake, the farther away a boat is the more

  • the bottom of the boat will disappear, and you'll basically just see the mast of the

  • boat.

  • And as a boat goes farther and farther away the last thing you will see is the very top

  • of the mast of that boat, and that's because the boat is actually going over the horizon

  • that's curvedand that means that as it goes farther and farther away you see less

  • and less of the bottom of it, and more of the top of that.

  • You can see that with binoculars by an ocean, by a lake, it's really easy.

  • That wouldn't happen if the Earth were flatyou would simply see the boat getting smaller

  • and smaller and smaller as it went farther away, but you'd be able to see the whole thing

  • with the same proportions.

  • Now, another way that you can tell that we're on a sphere is to think about how there's

  • something called the tropics on the Earth, and the tropics are places near the equator

  • of the earth were sometimes the sun is overhead in the sky.

  • This was actually something that the Greeks used, not only to prove that the Earth was

  • round about 2000 years ago, but they actually measured the circumference of the Earth, accurate

  • to within just a couple percent.

  • 2,000 years ago we've known that the Earth was round.

  • There was a really brilliant Greek scientist called Eratosthenes, and Eratosthenes noticed

  • that there was a town called Syene, and on a certain date the sun would actually shine

  • straight down to the bottom of a well.

  • That meant the sun was directly overhead; you could look down a well and see the sun

  • shining back at you.

  • And on the very same date, farther away in the city of Alexandria, that didn't happen.

  • The sun was not directly overhead, it was a slight angle, and all that Eratosthenes

  • did was he measured the difference in the angle of the sun.

  • It was straight overhead in Syene; in Alexandria it was a little bit less than overhead, and

  • he rationed that that change in angle from one city to another was probably indicative

  • of us being on a curved surface, and you could make all kinds of measurements even between

  • those two cities and see that the angles were differentthe sun was at a different place

  • in the sky.

  • Using this, he actually measured the circumference of the Earth, and he got it right 2,000 years

  • ago.

  • So another really simple proof is that on any given date, at different cities and different

  • places around the world, the sun is at different angles in the sky.

  • That wouldn't happen if the Earth wasn't round.

  • Then there are some other proofs that are a little more obscure, but they're actually

  • really lovely.

  • One is to observe what happens during a lunar eclipse.

  • Now, a lunar eclipse happens when the Earth casts a shadow on the moon.

  • The moon actually goes dark, in fact, if you've seen one you can actually see the Earth's

  • shadow go across the moon, and when the moon is entirely in the Earth's shadow the moon

  • looks kind of dark and even kind of red-colored; it's really, really beautiful.

  • What's happening, in that case, is that the sun is on one side of the Earththe Earth

  • is in the middleand the Earth is casting a shadow on the moon, and as the shadow moves

  • across the moon you'll notice that the shadow is curved, it's round.

  • And so something like the sun that's bigger than the Earth and is able to cast a shadow

  • of the Earth on the moon can actually show you the shape of the Earth.

  • "Ah-ha!" you might say, "but could the Earth to be a disk?

  • Could it be flat but it's actually still shaped like a disk, not like a sphere?"

  • There was a Greek scientist called Aristarchus and what he noticed was that you can get a

  • lunar eclipse at many different angles where the sun is; sometimes the shadow goes straight

  • across the moon, sometimes it just kind of glances the moonjust a little bit is in

  • shadow just on the top or on the bottom.

  • From every different vantage point, every different angle the sun is casting a shadow,

  • you always get a perfectly curved shadow.

  • The only shape that can cast a shadow that's curved from any direction you put the light

  • is a sphere.

  • So people have known that the Earth is spherical for thousands of years.

  • It's not okay to say that the Earth is flat.

  • This is some sort of strange denial, I don't know where it comes from, and it's something

  • where I keep getting this question.

  • We really need to put this question to bed because we've known the Earth is a sphere

  • for a long time.

  • There's even some well-meaning people who say, "I don't really believe the Earth is

  • flat, but I'm not really sure what to think about it."

  • And they've asked me some interesting questions, like they've heard that space is a very hot,

  • that when you go up above the atmosphere the temperature of space is millions of degrees,

  • which is true.

  • The problem is there's basically no air at all.

  • So the gas right around the Earth is actually millions of degrees hot.

  • That's actually true, but there's almost none of it, there's almost nothing.

  • Like one single proton whizzes by you at a temperature of a million degrees, it's not

  • the same as temperature in the air, it's not the same thing at all.

  • So that's one that I get sometimes.

  • And the other one is—I actually said this to somebody, and I couldn't believe they had

  • never thought of itthat with binoculars you can see planets, you can see Saturn and

  • Jupiter, you can see Mars with a telescope, the sun and the moon, everything else you

  • see in the solar system is a sphere.

  • So we're the one thing that is different?

  • And that actually made somebody who was more interested in actually hearing information,

  • that actually got them to think.

  • They were like, "You're righteverything else we take a picture of is a sphere!"

So, Oscar, you asked the question, "What are some of the easiest ways that you can prove

字幕と単語

ワンタップで英和辞典検索 単語をクリックすると、意味が表示されます

B1 中級

地球平板説を否定する3つの証拠|ビッグシンクトップテン2018|ミッシェル・ターラー (3 proofs that debunk flat-Earth theory | Big Think Top Ten 2018 | Michelle Thaller)

  • 23 1
    左孟民 に公開 2021 年 01 月 14 日
動画の中の単語