Placeholder Image

字幕表 動画を再生する

  • We've all been there: after a long day at work, you sit down and binge-read some Arthurian

  • romances.

  • They're calledilluminated manuscripts” - because they're illuminated with illustrations

  • in the borders,

  • colorful drawings, and veryspecial doodles in the margins.

  • But among all those steroidal rabbits and this hooded person laying literal eggs,

  • there's actually a theme...

  • A lot of medieval knights in these manuscripts are...fighting snails.

  • Why is this happening?

  • The largest snail alive is 15.5 inches, snout to tail.

  • So why does this knight look like he's in for the fight of his life?

  • Illuminated manuscripts were handwritten.

  • Scribes painstakingly transcribed the same bibles, devotionals, and stories.

  • They also decorated the margins.

  • By the 1960s, one scholar thought those margins were worth attention.

  • Lillian Randall was particularly intrigued byThe Snail

  • in Gothic Marginal Warfare.”

  • She developed a theory about why a book like this might include a winged knight fleeing

  • snails.

  • And why it showed up again and again and again.

  • Randall found more than 70 snail-fighting heroes in just 29 manuscripts,

  • most of which were made between 1290 and 1310.

  • Pray for yourself, knight.

  • Pray that the snail will kill you quickly.

  • Sometimes the margins riffed on the text, sometimes they were disconnected.

  • But Randall connected them to historical stereotypes.

  • The biggest was that theLombardswere greedy, mean, and cowardly.

  • The Lombards were a Germanic people that had invaded Italy.

  • They were warriors.

  • But in 772, they were badly beaten by Charlemagne.

  • That permanently stained their reputation.

  • By the late 1200s — when those snail pictures started getting popularthe Lombards had

  • become lenders and pawnbrokers spread throughout Europe.

  • They didn't have full rights, they couldn't even own arms.

  • But they did have power.

  • That combination of power and impotence, Randall argued, made them targets.

  • Snailwas the appropriate insult.

  • Snails carried their houses on their backs as they retreated, just as the Lombards had

  • from Charlemagne.

  • They were slimy, like a lot of Europeans probably saw their lenders.

  • Calling Lombards snails was an anti-foreign slur

  • that later grew into a bigger trope.

  • It appeared in what was probably a medieval pattern book, with models that helped other

  • scribes draw.

  • And snails showed up in many different combinations later on.

  • Here's a snail/monkey/rabbit battle royale from the 1400s.

  • Snails were slow.

  • But they spread.

  • We can't be certain what the knights and snails meant because they meant different

  • things as the image became a cliche.

  • The same way people don't explain their memes today, scribes didn't annotate their

  • games in the margins.

  • Randall's argument fits with the timing and history.

  • But people also speculate that snails represented the slowness of time, or the insulation of

  • the ruling class.

  • We can only be certain about one thing.

  • The snails reveal something, along with everything else in the margins.

  • As scribes labored over transcriptions of hallowed works, reproducing every line,

  • they snuck in additions, jokes, and riffs, in the margins of the text.

  • The drawings were fantasies.

  • But they were made by artists who sought to parody the indignities and absurdities of

  • their own world.

  • The margins were the only space left.

  • So they turned them into a self-portrait.

  • Except for this guy.

  • He's just going to get murdered by a snail.

  • So this video just scratches the surface when it comes to weird medieval art and possible

  • interpretations.

  • Michael Camille wrote a whole book about art in the margins and he highlights one figure:

  • it's the gryllus, and he's supposed to represent bodily appetites.

  • It's very cute and a little disgusting.

We've all been there: after a long day at work, you sit down and binge-read some Arthurian

字幕と単語

ワンタップで英和辞典検索 単語をクリックすると、意味が表示されます

B2 中上級

中世美術で騎士がカタツムリと戦った理由 (Why knights fought snails in medieval art)

  • 37 8
    April Lu に公開 2021 年 01 月 14 日
動画の中の単語