字幕表 動画を再生する
“There is total chaos in Venezuela — hunger,
lack of medicine, and latest, nearly the whole country
had a blackout.
But most of the conversation in the States
focuses on what Trump is doing about Venezuela,
and rumors are spreading that the U.S. is considering
military intervention.”
“All options are on.”
“Hands off Venezuela!
Hands off Venezuela!”
“This movement on the American left
against any U.S. involvement in Venezuela
is gaining traction.
We’ve got Noam Chomsky, Roger Waters, Oliver Stone,
Boots Riley, Ilhan Omar, AOC, Jill Stein, and Bernie
agreeing with them.”
“Why have you stopped short of calling Maduro
of Venezuela a dictator?”
“Well — ”
“And of course, we’ve got this lovely guy.”
“Donald Trump, hands off Venezuela!”
“It is not a good look when your slogan
is co-opted by a tyrannical dictator.
Now, Trump usually loves authoritarians,
but this time it seems like it’s the liberals who
are siding with one.
Now, I am not a pro-Trump military hawk.
For reference, my spirit animal
is Ruth Bader Ginsburg in workout clothes.
But this movement is dangerously
glorifying a brutal dictator and promoting inaction.
And that is the worst combination
for ordinary Venezuelans.
First off, if you look closely at these protests,
it’s very unlikely you’ll bump into an actual Venezuelan.”
“Where are you from?”
“Where am I from?”
“Yeah.”
“Here.”
“Here?”
“Yeah.”
“Where are you from?”
“Philadelphia.”
“Where are you from?”
“No comment.”
“Trust me, if this was an actual Venezuelan protest,
it might look more like this.
Second, let me remind you what’s going on back home.
Inflation is at 2.69 million percent.
Bolivars are so worthless, people are literally
making origami out of them.
Mass malnutrition and shortages of medicine
have caused life expectancy to fall 3.5 years,
and at least 3 million people have fled their country,
causing a Syria-level refugee crisis.
I mean, things are so bad, kidnappers
have stopped kidnapping because people
can’t pay ransom.
Some pundits of the left claim Venezuela
is in economic ruin because of U.S. sanctions,
but they are wrong.
Venezuela’s economy completely collapsed in 2016
after decades of corruption and incompetence of Chavez
and Maduro’s nacro-kleptocratic
governments.
Until very recently, US sanctions
were only travel bans and frozen bank accounts
on specific government officials —
like, for example, Chavez’s former bodyguard, who
accepted over $1 billion in bribes,
has three private jets, and owns more horses
than a Revolutionary War battalion.
One of them is named Tinkerbell.
That has nothing to do with how corrupt this guy is,
but I just found it fascinating.
In January, the sanctions on the state oil company
were designed to stop funding Maduro’s regime
and their flamboyant watches.
While Venezuela’s situation is a dumpster fire,
hands off Venezuela advocates seem
to be living on another planet.”
“We just returned from two weeks in Venezuela,
and we are happy to report that there
is no humanitarian crisis in Venezuela.”
“I’m sorry.
What?”
“Just the crisis of U.S. imperialism.”
“It is true that the U.S.’s history
of meddling in Latin America should give people pause.
But complete inaction out of fear of the U.S.
repeating its interventionist mistake from the '80s
is not the answer.
Hands off can actually mean blood on your hands.
So what does American support look like?
Supporting Venezuela’s efforts to restore democracy.
The U.S. and 50 other countries recently
recognized opposition leader Juan Guaido
as the new interim president.”
“Is this a coup d’état?”
“Trained by the C.I.A.”
“This is regime change number 68.”
“Juan Guaido is not an American right-wing puppet
leading an illegitimate coup, but a Social Democrat
appointed by the National Assembly,
the only remaining democratically elected
institution left in Venezuela.
Guaido’s job is to ensure free and fair elections,
because news flash, the last election
was not free or fair.
Dictators aren’t really into that.
The problem is Venezuela is being
used to further polarize political agendas
on both sides.
Republicans are trying to drum up another Red Scare
for their 2020 campaign.”
“What it’s doing in Venezuela.”
“That worked out so great in Venezuela.”
“Look at Venezuela.”
“America will never be a socialist country.”
“While the left is using it to counter Trump,
because it’s what you do.
What unfortunately gets lost in the crossfire
is the actual Venezuelan people,
people who want a chance to live with electricity, food,
jobs, schools, medicine and a vote that actually counts.
If there’s one value liberal America appreciates,
it’s human rights.
So let’s stop this morally relativist, hands-off
approach that is just a euphemism for inaction.
Let’s provide humanitarian aid and support efforts
to restore democracy and prioritize people’s rights
to life, health and freedom.”