Thiswebinarispartof a newfreeSiri's beingofferedbytheUniversityofMinnesotaAlumniAssociation, wherewe'rehavingconversationswithexpertsaboutcareerlifeinlearningtopics.
ThewebinarisbeingrecordedandwillbeviewableafterwardsatMinnesotaAlumniDotorGEBackslashalumniWebinarSirisJustgiveus a fewbusinessdaystoepostedonourwebsite, andwe'llalsosend a reminderemailtoparticipantswhoarejoiningustoday.
Andifyou'reonTwitterrightnow, tweetatuswiththehashtagyou m andwebinar.
He's also a professorinthedivisionofEnvironmentalHealthSciencesattheSchool.
PublicHealth.
A professorintheTechnologicalLeadershipInstituteintheCollegeofScienceandEngineeringinanadjunctprofessorinthemedicalschoolhereattheUniversityofMinnesota.
Heisalso a memberoftheInstituteofMedicineofftheNationalAcademyofSciencesintheCouncilofForeignRelations.
Dr.
AusterHomeistheauthorofmorethan 315 papersandabstracts, including 21 bookchapters, andis a frequentlyinvitedguestlectureronthetopicofepidemiologyofinfectiousdiseases.
Hehasreceivednumeroushonorsforhisworkandhasbeentherecipientofsixmajorresearchawardsfromthe N.
Thankyouverymuchandthankyouforhavingmetodayoverthenext 45 to 50 minutes, I willsharewithyouanoverviewofwhatonemightcall a citizen's guidetotheEbolaepidemic.
Andindoingthat, I hopethat I willbeabletoprovidesomeconstructivecommentsaboutwherewe'reatandwherewe'regoing.
Firstofall, letmejustsay I havenofinancialrelationshipstodisclosehere, and I alsodonot, uh, willnotdiscusssendingofflabelorinvestigationsfrommypresentation.
And I knowlessaboutEbolatodaythan I didsixmonthsago.
Sopleasetakethatinformationprovidedherewiththatacknowledgementtostartout, letmejustcomeintoandtwoquotes, I think, reallysettheoverallstageroomtalkabouttoday.
I thinkyou'llseetodaythatwecansafelysaythatwe'relearning a lotaboutEbolais a virusasaninfectiousdiseaseandas a interfacewithglobalpublichealthpracticeinmedicalcare, andwehave a lotmoretolearnsecondball.
RichardFeinman, theformerNobelPrizelaureate, onesaid, For a successfultechnology, realitymusttakeprecedenceoverpublicrelations, fornaturecannotbefull.
I thinkwecanalsoaddherethatfor a successfulpublichealthintervention, realitymusttakepresidents, andwe'relearning a greatdealinthatregard.
Nowthenextslideisreally a contextslidethatshareswithyou a senseofhowandwhywemightbeconcernedaboutEbolain a differentwaytodaythanwehaveinthepast.
Asyouseehere, youcanseehowworldpopulationhasincreasedfrom 18 50 to 2000 todayatabout 7.5 billionpeoplewanted.
Whilethetimehasn't gottenanyfastertogetaroundtheworldsince 19 fifties, theamountofpeoplegoodsitemsofthethingsthatgoaroundtheworldhatthesetwofactorsofreallycombinedtomakefor a potentialforEbolatoday, too, dothingsthatfrom a publichealthperspectivethatwehadnotreallyonceconsideredforexample, oneoftheareasofthefastestgrowinggrowthinhumanpopulationisactuallyintheequatorialbeltofAfricawiththenewmegacitiesthere, andthisisclearlyanimportantaspectofwhat's happenedintermsoftherecentmonthsinWestAfrica.
Nowtogive a basicbackgroundontheEbolavirusinhumaninfectionwasnamedaftertheEbolaRiverandwhatwasthenZairenowtheDemocraticRepublicoftheCongowasfirstdiscoveredin 1976 in a veryremoteruralvillagearea.
Andinthisregard, uh, youcansummarize, reallybysayingEbolaishardlypayingthehumanspeciesbeforethecurrentWestAfricaoutbreakandreallyisanimportantcontextpointagaintounderstandwhatdoweknowandnotknowaboutthisinfectionnow, intermsofhowEbolavirusistransmitted, thisisanareathatweknow a lotabout.
Butifyoucouldimagineourknowledgebaseforthisislike a normalcurveor 98% ofthecurveeyesfairlywellknowntousandsomethingthatwecandescribewithsomeandChrissyclearlydetails, the 1% oneithersideofthecurveisyetreallyuncleartouson.
Wehavethingstolearnaboutitso, butwhatwedoknowisthatwithdirectcontactfromaneffectivepersonoranimalbodyfluidsincludingblood, vomit, fecesandpossiblyperspirationis a theprimarymechanismfortransmission.
Thecurrentoutbreakshighlightedquestionsabouttransmission, forexample, Earlyon, weplaced a greatdealofemphasisonthepresenceorabsence.
Now, I mentionedearlier, justasanexampleofthequestionsaboutwhatweknowanddon't know.
Hereis a verynicereviewbytheWorldHealthOrganizationBulletResponseTeam, publishedintheNewEnglandJournalofMedicineinmidOctober, summarizingthe 1st 9 monthsoftheepidemicwithsomekindofsomecommentsonfutureprojections.
Oneofthethingstonotehere, despitethiscasedefinitionrequiringfeverorelsetobetestedforEbolavirusandfoundpositive, whichwouldfavorinfact, findingpatientswithfeveronLee, 87.1% ofcasesreported a feverthroughoutthecourseoftheirillness.
Thisis a pointtomakethatwehavetobeverycarefulaboutabsolutes.
Andtherehavebeen, I think, a effortbymanytodo a betterjobofthatearlyoninthepublicconcernaboutEbola, wedid, as a publichealthcommunity, makeveryabsolutestatementsoutof, I think, a obviousneedtoourdesiretoassurethepublicaboutvariousaspectsoftransmission.
Today.
We'lltalkmoreaboutthataswerealizethatnoteverythingisgoingtobeinclearblack, a wifeifwelookatthediseaseitself.
IfyoulookatthisverynicecartoonfromtheCDC, youcanseethisreservoirbeingportrayedasbeingbassandvariablepossiblethatthatistheprimaryandonLeeReservoirwithintransmissionintootheranimalspeciescalledsalveatticcycleAndthereyoucanseetransmission, whetheritbe, uh, somehumanprimates, batsandotheranimals, thengettingtohumansforcontactwiththeseanimalspecies, mostoftenusuallyaround a foodsourceexposurewheresomeonewhofinds a deadanimalor a sickanimalonandthenbasicallypreparesthatfor a mealwithcontactoccurringwiththebodyfluidsofthatanimal, westillhavemuchtolearnaboutthiswholesomaticcycle, wherethevirusresidesinbetweenthetimeswhenwedon't haveheavenhadoutbreaks.
Welookatthebelthereofwherewe'retalkingaboutcountrieswithindexreportedcasesincountriesatriskwithoutreportedcases, youget a senseoflookingattherainforestandwherewe'relookingatthepotentialforthesecases.
WestAfrica, asweknowthethreeprimaryeffectedcountriestoday, shouldn't havebeen a surpriseyet.
In a sense, theywerebecausewehadnotseeninoursportingsomeyourhistoryEbolavirustransmissionThere.
WebeginfollowingthissituationinMarchatourCenterforInfectiousDiseaseResearchandPolicy, recognizingthatinitiallythisseemedtobejustanotherEbolaoutbreakinthiscase, in a slightlydifferentlocationintheequatorialbelt.
Butitbecameveryclear.
Towusatleastearlyonthatthiswas a differentsituationand a numberofNGOs, particularlytheDoctorsWithoutBordersorMSF.
I madeitveryclearthattheybelievethatthiswasdifferent, thatitwasn't beingbroughtundercontrol, usingthesamekindofpublichealthinterventionmethodsofidentifyingcases, quicklyisolatingthemandmedicalcareandfollowingupcontext.
Nowsomeofthisclearlyhadtodowith a lackofadequateresponsetoduetothelackofpubliccaliphinmedicalcareinfrastructureintheaffectedcountries.
I wrote a pieceactuallyinTheWashingtonPostinlateJuly, inwhich, uh, thiswasbeforethecaseshadoccurredinwerebroughttothepublic's attentionaroundAmericanphysiciansbroughthomewhichwouldseemtobe a a veryimportanteventintermsofhighlightingtheissue.
Oneofthethingsthatyou'llnoteinthesecondparagraph I startedenforcement.
Today's outbreakisverydifferentandtryingtoexplainthatthisreallydidseemtobevery, verydifferentandwhat I hypothesizeinthispiecewasitwasn't becausethevirushadchangedbecauseAfricachangedand I'm notsosurethat's thecasetoday.
I thinkaswegainmoreinformation, wemayseethatthisvirusisslightlydifferentintermsofitsabilitytocausediseaseonandsuchthingsasvirusloadortighterandsoforth.
Butthebottomlineisitdidfallinto a geographicareawherethehealthandpublichealthinfrastructureweregenerallyvirtuallyniltoabsent, andthefactthattherewasintensepersonalcrowdinginfor a lackof a betterterm, theslumsofthemajorcitiesintheruralarea.
Wealsohadsomesuccessesearlyon, andthisisoneofthethingsthathasmadethissituation a bitmorecomplicatedintermsunderstanding.
Ifyoulookhereagain, thethreeofimpactedcasesbut I wanttohighlightthisslidebecauseoftheironecaseoccurringinSenegalearlyon, aswellas a casethatwasintroducedintoNigeria.
LetmespendmoretimeintheNigeriansituationwhereinfactanindividualwhoisinfectedinLiberiaflewtoLagos, Nigeria.
Itoccurredat a timewhenthepublichealthcaresystemwasactuallyorthepublichealthsystemwasonstrike.
Andthisindividualishospitalizedactuallyin a privatehospitalwhichhaveprovidedandyousense a highlevelofcare.
Thiswas a goodthingbecauseofthefactthatitreallylimitedhiscontactandpotentialin a lackofadequatehealthcaresettingtobecaredfor.
And I thinkoneofthereallyremarkableachievementssofartodatewasthecombinedeffortoftheNigerianHealthandPublicHealthSystems, alongwiththeCDCtoeactuallylimitandstopthis I'm goingchainoftransmission.
Itoccurredagainprimarilyinhealthcareworkers.
Thisoutbreakrequiredover 1000 peoplebefollowedupand I onlyshowthisbecausethisslidehasoftenbeenusedinthestoryinNigeriaisanexampleofhowwecanstillstopthisinAfrica.
I wouldsuggestyoudothesamepatiententeredNigeriabutspenttimeintheslumsofLagosandwasnotdetectedearly.
ButitpointsoutthevulnerabilityoftherestofAfricatowhat I calltheinfectiousdiseaseforestfireofthethreeaffectedcountries, sendingsparksthroughoutotherareasofAfricaintheworld.
It's unclear, but I thinktoputthisintoperspective, which, bytheway, rememberwehadonly 2400 casestotalinalloftheEbolaepidemicsuptothispoint.
Soitgivesyousomeperspective.
Butwherearewegoing?
Therehavebeen a numberofattemptstoprovidesomeestimate, and I showthisslideit's onlyasofAugust, anditwantedintentionallytogiveyou a senseofthisearlyincreaseincaseswhichsetthetoneforhowpeoplemadeestimatesforfuturecasenumbersinthisveryearlywindowofjust a fewweeks.
Ifyoulookatunreportedhowyoufactinthisinbecausehe's reportedcaseshere, I actuallythinkthatthisestimateisactuallyquiteremarkablygoodintermsoftheoverallassessmentofwhatwasgoingon, However, thesamelikethatthatwaspublished, theSinisterDiseaseControlandPreventionpublishedanarticlesuggestingthattheyextrapolatedtrips.
I thinkwejusthavetoadmititthatthesenumbersreallyweregrossoverestimatebasedondatathat I thinkwasunfortunately, veryrobustifonelooksnecessarilyowned, whichwouldhaveaccountedforabouthalfofthesecases, remember, thisisonlytwocountries, notthreecountriesnecessarilyowninLiberia.
Weshowcouldhaveexpectedupwardsof 200 to 250,000 casesreported, andwe'renotgonnabeanywhereclosetothat.
And I thinkthiswas, uhshouldbe a soberingmessagetoallofusabouttheneedweneedtotakeinhowwereportorprojectfuturecases.
Mymessagehasbeenforovertwoand 1/2 months.
There's gonnabelotsandlotsofcasesandlotsofmonths.
Thedeathsand I don't knowwhatthatnumberis, but I thinkweneedtohavemorethathonestyintermsofourpresentations.
Ifonelookstoday.
Thesearethenumbersfromthisrecent W H O reportwithyellowdotsandsizerepresentingthenumberofcasesinthepast 21 days, youcanseetheongoingactivityprimarilyinSierraLeone, evencontinuinginLiberia.
Allthoseison a mission.
ThemomenttheinformationinLiberiaclearlydoespointto a reducednumberofnewcasesandinsomecasesactuallylevelingofftoreduction.
Becauseoftheconcernaboutmandatoryinformationissue, I thinkthisclearlycannotexplainthereduction.
Itmaybeinpart, buttherehavebeenveryclear, I think, inevidentactivitiesinLiberiatoreducetransmission.
Umandand I giveah, theCDC a lotofcreditherebecausetheyhavebeenverymuch a partofthatwholeactivity, andthey'veprovidedseveralnightsdocumentsthatdiscussingthatthey'restill.
However, as I pointedoutthatconcerninSierraLeonewithnewinfectioncontrolchainscontinuingandaslongasthisisoccurringinonecountryitcanoccurinanycountry, meaningthatthisisyouronlyasgoodasbasicallyyourlastdayseffortthatifweletupthetheacceleratorofresponsethatcouldseetransmissionclearlymovedbackoutofareasthathadpreviouslyhadmajoractivitythanreadreducedactivity.
I have, likeinthis, insomecases, towhat I callfireworkstransmission, whereupuntilatleastthelastmonthinLiberia, we'vehadexamplesofwheretherehasbeensubstantialactivitythan a periodofreducedactivity, whichisunexplained.
We'vehad a lotofworktodoand I thinkthesearticlesarebothcorrect.
I thinktheyreflecttheongoingdifferencesweseeintransmissionbygeographicareabytimeandbyoureffortsandoneofthethings, I thinkwe'regonnahavetobecomemorecomfortablewiththisuncertaintythatgenerallyspeaking, westillhaveanupwardgrowingoperateinatleasttwoofthethreecountriesinoneofthecountry's.
But I thinkthatoneofthethingsthisoutbreakisdoingthischallengingourthinkingabouthowdowedoeffectiveEbolatreatmenttobothimprovepatientoutcome, butalsotobetterimpactonthepublichealthaspectsoftheepidemic.
Thisis a articlefromtodayfromBBChighlightsandnumberongoingproblemswe'vehadwithinfrastructure.
I thinkthisisanotherareawhereCDCplayed a verykeyroleearlyon, tryingtohighlighttheimportanceofWestAfricanwhyweneedtokeepoureyeonthatareaandourresponsereallyisolatedin a sense, tothatarea.
Rightnow, weknowwe'renotgoingtomeetthedeadlinesthatwereoriginallysuggestedbythe U.
N for 70% ofcasesbeingtreatedandensuring 70% ofsafeburialsbyDecember 1st, thispartoftheissueinSierraLeoneprogressinLiberiahasbeenMaur, butagain, recentreportedoutbreaksandscatteredvillagesoutthroughoutLiberiaraisedquestionsaboutthat.
Yetearlyontherewerelotsofdiscussionsabouttheinadequateresponseandwhywehadnotdone a betterjobwithquicklyrecognizingthisintheAugust 28thWorldHealthOrganizationEvil a roadmapwhichwasfirstlaidoutofresponse, whichsomeveryquicklybecameoutdatedbecauseoftheoverwhelmingoutbreak.
Mypointistake a stepback, everyoneYouknow, noonereallyisatfaultforhavingmissedtheearlysignsandbeenabletodothekindofcriticalearlyworkbecauseeverybodydid.
I don't carewhatcountryyou'rein.
I don't carewhatgovernmentyouworkfor.
Whatprivateagency, uhareintermsofinternational.
Wereallydohave a criticalissuehereintermsof, uh, howweresponded.
Thisarticlefirsthighlightedthepossibilitymajorfoodcrisisistthe e f a o andothersjustyesterdaymadecommentsaboutthisveryissuethatundertheseverydireconditionsinthesethreeaffectedcountries, weneedtobemindfulof.
Thiswillincludeboththe G s K chimphadnovaccineaswellasthenewlinkMercUhuhVSDvaccine.
There's muchtoworkoutwiththis, though.
However, I'm partof a groupcochair a groupwithChairmanJeremyFarahfrom, uh, theWellcomeTrustthatactuallyhasformedwhatit's calledtheTeam B 27 internationalexpertsthatareactuallyworkingtocomeupwithalternativestrategiesandplansthatcanchallengeourcurrentefforts.
Getusthesafest, mosteffectivevaccineinAfricaassoonaspossibleintheamountsthatweneedin a waythatthelocalpopulationwilluseit.
I justwanttomentionbrieflythereare a numberofVoglertreatmentsunderstudy, also a numberoftherapeuticcompounds, onethatwehaveheard a lotabout a Z map.
A triplemonoclonalantibodycocktail.
There's Indianabodyinfusion.
I won't gointothatmoretodaytosaythatthathasbecome a commonresponsekindofthing, too.
WhilewerecognizethatprimarycarejustfloorIDs, electrolytessupportarereallythefirstlineandmostimportantlyinrightnow, Eboladrugsmayhave a potentialrealroleinthisoutbreak.
OngoingItwillbe a challenge, ofcourse, economicallyandagainfrom a a vexorfrom a trumptreatmentefficacyin a manufacturingstandpointlicensesuretogetthesedrugsintimePairofcareforthisreallyillegalofpatients.
We'velearnedclearlyfromtheUnitedStatesthatwith a kindoftherapeuticinterventionswe'veseenusedhereinpeoplebeingtreatedtheUnitedStates, wecantakeEbolafrombeinganalmostalwaysfataldisease, tauoneinwhichitisnot.
Letmejustsaythat I won't gointothismuchbeyondthefactthatthatweallrecognizeandunderstandthechallengesthatwehadn't.
WehavethefirstEbolacasesdiagnosedinTexasandwhatthatmeantbothintermsofthepublic's understandingofwhat a bowlelementtothiscountryaremessagingin, howweapproachthatmessagingonandalsojusthowweprotectedourhealthcareworkers.
EveryhealthcareworkerintheUnitedStatesneedstobeabletorecognize a possiblecase, meaningthatinfact, ifsomeonehasbeeninWestAfricaorhascontactwithsomeonewhoisinWestAfricawasillandon.
And I shouldsayduringtheroughly 21 daytimeperiodandpresentswithvomiting, diarrheawithwithoutfever, youhavethiobeabletoevaluatethosepatientssafelyfortheworkersandeffectivelyforthepatient.
And I thinktodaywe'remuchfurtheralonginthiscountrywith a systeminplaceateachcommunitylevelareatoactuallyhelphealthcareworkersidentifypotentialpatients, movethemsafelyto a placeforadequateevaluationcanbedone.
Ifyoudon't knowwhereyou'regoing, anyroadwillgetyouthereandthisis a challengeforusbecauseinpartwedon't knowwherewe'regoinginsomecases, becauseconditionsonthegroundthefutureisveryunpredictableandwe'regonnaaftertheybasicallymakingupourtravelitineraryaswegoandthisissomethingwejusthavetogetmorecomfortable.
Andfinally I concludebyjustsayingasevidencewascrucialinsaidduringthisholidayseason, arethesetheshadowsofthethingsthatwillbeortheshadowsofthethingsthatmaybeonlyAnd I thinkthatwestillhave a lotofquestionsaboutwhatthatwillbeintermsofthefuturewithEbolainAfricaanduntilwehaveanadequateandsafethatscene, whichwehopeisnotmany, manymonthsoff.
Butitwillbesomemonthsoff.
Wereallyareleftwithourprimarypublichealthandmedicalcarepracticestotrytostopandreducethisparticularepidemicsowiththat, I'llconclude, and I willgoaheadandopenituptoquestionsandanycomments.
I'm confidentatthispoint I thinkthatthevaccinewillwork.
I believethatwhatatleastoneofthecandidatevaccineshas a veryhighpossibilityofworking, Butwe'llseethisisthequestioniscominginfrom a numberofdifferentpeople.
Butyouknowmesayingwehave a lottolearnaboutEbola.
There's noabsolutes, butwhydo I say a travelbanisnot a goodidea.
Letmejustmaketwopointsaboutthatissueoneyearsisthatwecould a CZwelearnedinHIV, AIDSandforeigndesiresandsoforth.
And I thinkinthelast 45 dayssaidthatthisisnotgoingtocontinuetobelotsandlotsofcasescomingoutofWestAfrica.
I thinkthe U.
S government's followuprightnowofindividualscomingoutofWestAfrica, evenwithdirectflights O r, atleastwithoneticketflightsmeaningthattheymaytransferinEurope.
Wereallyarepickingthoseup, and I thinkthatinthatregard, I feelveryconfidentthatwe'rewe'redoingquite a bitaboutthat.
Ah, a lotofquestionshereaboutmonitoring.
I thinkmostofyouknowrightnowis I justmentioned I justreemphasizeitagainthatinfact, I believewe'recapturingmostifnotalmostall, oftheindividualsfindoutofWestAfricacomingtotheUnitedStates.
StatehealthdepartmentsarebeingnotifiedAh, byHomelandSecurity, workingwiththeCDCintermsofpeoplearrivingintheindividualstatesfromsomelocationinfromWestAfrica, and I thinkthesystemisactuallygoingquitewell.
Wereallyareabletolearnofpeoplewhomayhavebeenexposedandtoworkwiththemon a dailybasisatthesametime.
Letmejustsaythere's a sensethatpeoplewhomightbeinfectedwouldnotpresentthemselvestomedicalcarequickly.
Earlymedicalcareis a keytosurvival, andifyouhaveadequatemedicalcare, youbasicallyincreaseyourchancesdramaticallyofsurvivingthatillness.
Sowhywouldyounotifyouhadyourfirsthangyouandyouthoughtthatyoumightactuallythatmightbe a symptomofearlyonsteadybullet, notwantingtoseekmedicalcareveryquickly.
Sothere's a realincentivehereforpeoplethiotobeabletoAh, VailHealthcarequicklyandtoe.
Wannaseekit?
Notwanttorunfrom.
Sowe'vealsohad a questionhereIfyoushouldcontinuetravelingtoAfrica.
Wehaveseveralquestionsaboutthat.
I wouldsayrightnowifyou'renotintheaffectedcountrieseither, uh, SierraLeone, GuineaorLiberiaornow, Molly, really.
But I wouldnotchangeanyofyourtraveltoAhAfricaoutsideofthesefourcountriesrightnow, basedonthebullet, evenifyoudohave a needtogotooneofthesefourcountries, thatwouldsaynot.
TheissueofEbolaterrorismit's a questionhascomeupmultipletimesheretoo.
Isthis a fewusableor a realsecurityissue, oristhisjustparanoia?
Andletmeanswerthisquestionin a waythatis a bituncomfortableformetosay.
I refusetotalkaboutEbolaterrorisminpublicsettingsfromthestandpointthat I thinkthatdiscussingitwouldnotbehelpfulintermsofthepotentialencouragementtooccur, Uh, I thinkthatshouldtellyouourconcernsaboutitandwhatcouldbedone.
Andsoit's a realissue.
Weneedtobemindfulofit.
But I thinkthatthelesssaidaboutitintermsofah, whiter, howorwhyisprobablybetterrightnowandjustsayyes.