Placeholder Image

字幕表 動画を再生する

  • The drive through the world's most secure prison is beautiful.

  • The federal government's only supermax prison, known as ADX,

  • is 90 miles south of Denver.

  • Standing outside the building,

  • ADX looks like a newish suburban middle school.

  • (Laughter)

  • The lobby is clean and bright;

  • there's big windows and clear views of the mountains;

  • and a polite front-desk attendant with a kiosk selling travel mugs.

  • (Laughter)

  • On the wall is a large plaque that reads,

  • "The best prize that life offers is the chance to work hard

  • at work worth doing."

  • Just past it is a huge framed photo of Alcatraz.

  • And down the stairs, at the end of a long hallway,

  • are 400 men decaying in isolation cells.

  • I work on cases involving the constitutional rights of prisoners.

  • Now, people have differing views about prisoners' rights.

  • But there's something more people can agree on:

  • torture.

  • The US government says it doesn't use torture,

  • and we condemn other countries, like Iran and North Korea,

  • for their use of torture.

  • But some people think the so-called worst of the worst deserve it:

  • terrorists, mass murderers, the really "bad" people.

  • Now I personally believe that no one deserves to be tortured

  • by the US government.

  • But that's me.

  • (Applause)

  • No matter where you fall,

  • there's a few things I need you to understand

  • before I continue.

  • First, we do torture people here in America,

  • tens of thousands of them every day.

  • It's called solitary confinement.

  • It's done in our names, using our tax dollars,

  • behind closed doors.

  • And as a result,

  • we're undermining the core values of our justice system.

  • Built with state-of-the-art technology,

  • ADX has nearly perfected solitary confinement.

  • Each man spends 23 hours a day

  • alone in a cell the size of a small bathroom.

  • Virtually every aspect of his life occurs in that cell.

  • But aside from sleeping and eating,

  • which he does within an arm's reach of his toilet,

  • there aren't many aspects of life.

  • Correctional officers push food trays through slots in the doors

  • and take the men to solitary exercise cages

  • that are referred to by prisoners and staff alike,

  • without irony, as dog runs.

  • Other than that,

  • these men are locked in cement closets,

  • all day, every day.

  • Two steps forward, two steps back.

  • That's it.

  • They can't see the nearby mountains or any trees --

  • "nothing living, not so much as a blade of grass,"

  • is how one man in ADX described it.

  • Some people report that after years of not looking at anything

  • further than 10 feet away,

  • their eyesight has deteriorated so much

  • that they can't focus on faraway objects anymore.

  • The isolation is so deep and profound

  • that one of our clients would lie on the floor of his cell for hours,

  • just hoping to catch a glimpse of someone's feet

  • as they walked past the door of his cell.

  • Another befriended a wasp that flew into his cell,

  • feeding it and talking to it like a friend.

  • Some try to communicate with fellow prisoners

  • by yelling through the shower drains.

  • Still though, many of these men lost their voices

  • after talking with us for just an hour.

  • Their vocal cords were out of practice speaking for that long.

  • We know the impact of long-term isolation is devastating.

  • This borders on common sense.

  • It's why harsh prison systems and torture regimes

  • routinely use solitary as a form of severe punishment.

  • And why none of us would tolerate having a loved one,

  • like a parent or a child,

  • locked alone in a small bathroom for days, let alone years.

  • Or decades.

  • In the course of representing that first client at ADX,

  • we learned about another man, Tommy Silverstein,

  • who the Federal Bureau of Prisons put in solitary confinement

  • under a "no human contact" order in 1983,

  • after he killed a corrections officer.

  • Tommy was 31 years old.

  • Now he's 66.

  • He's been in solitary confinement for 35 years.

  • Struggling to find the words to capture his experience of ADX,

  • Tommy, who has become an accomplished artist,

  • drew it instead.

  • Unless we start to change how we treat prisoners in this country,

  • he'll probably be there for the rest of his life.

  • Both John McCain and Nelson Mandela

  • said that of all the horrors they suffered in prison,

  • solitary confinement was the worst.

  • That's because solitary puts people at risk

  • of losing their grasp on who they are,

  • of how and whether they're connected to a larger world.

  • As psychologist Dr. Craig Haney explains,

  • that's because human identity is socially created.

  • We understand ourselves through our relationships with other people.

  • Solitary confinement can make you change what you think about yourself.

  • It can make you doubt whether you even have a self.

  • Some people in solitary aren't even sure they exist,

  • so they'll mouth off to a corrections officer

  • and end up getting shackled or beaten.

  • But at least then, they know they exist.

  • Over time, some of the men in ADX break down in obvious ways,

  • like banging their heads on the walls of their cells

  • or smearing themselves with feces.

  • Or attempting suicide, some of them successfully.

  • Many people cut themselves

  • just to feel the pain that keeps them tethered to the real world.

  • Others adjust,

  • showing no outward sign of mental illness.

  • But there's grave harm in the adjustment itself.

  • That's because the experience of long-term isolation

  • can paradoxically lead to social withdrawal.

  • At first, people are starved for human contact,

  • but over time,

  • it becomes disorienting, even frightening.

  • They can't handle it anymore.

  • All of this amounts to a prolonged social death.

  • The men in ADX are stuck in suspended animation.

  • Not really part of this world,

  • they're not really part of any world that's fully and tangibly human.

  • It's for all of these reasons that international human rights law

  • prohibits the use of long-term solitary confinement.

  • In fact, the UN has called on governments to ban the use of solitary

  • for more than 15 days.

  • As of today,

  • Tommy Silverstein has been in solitary for 12,815 days.

  • Now in judging other countries' human rights records,

  • the US State Department has called the use of long-term solitary

  • a human rights violation.

  • In 2009, for example,

  • State Department condemned Israel, Iran, Indonesia and Yemen

  • for their use of solitary.

  • But we allow it to happen on our own soil.

  • When a prison is located in the US instead of China,

  • when it's run by the federal government and not some rogue sheriff,

  • when it has state-of-the-art technology and gleaming floors,

  • not overcrowded cells and decrepit facilities,

  • it's harder to believe that torture happens there.

  • But it's important to entertain the idea that, sometimes, this too

  • is what torture looks like.

  • As a civil rights lawyer,

  • I believe it's important to ensure that people,

  • even those convicted of terrible crimes,

  • aren't tortured by our government.

  • And if this talk were a movie,

  • I'd tell you next about how we fought and fought and eventually won.

  • But this isn't a movie.

  • So I'll tell you, instead, about how deeply this injustice is hidden.

  • How difficult it is to expose it,

  • and why it's important that we do.

  • You'd think that lawyers, people who work in the justice system,

  • would know what happens in our prisons.

  • But I'm a lawyer, and I live less than two hours away from ADX.

  • And until we went to see that first client,

  • I didn't know anything about it.

  • I don't think that's an accident.

  • ADX walls itself off from public scrutiny.

  • In the 25 years since it opened,

  • it's allowed only a single visit by human rights organizations.

  • Journalists are routinely denied entry.

  • Mail is censored.

  • And even when rare family visits occur,

  • they're monitored by an unseen government official

  • who can cut the visit off without notice

  • if he thinks that the prisoner is talking in too much detail

  • about the conditions in ADX.

  • In China, in Russia, they keep out the human rights observers,

  • keep out the media, keep out the UN.

  • And so do we.

  • ADX is, in the words of one journalist,

  • "a black site on American soil."

  • We know that secrecy is a hallmark of places that torture.

  • But after years of shining a light,

  • we now know more about the conditions in Guantanamo

  • than we do at ADX.

  • Five years ago,

  • when there was a hunger strike and force-feeding at Guantanamo,

  • the same thing was happening at ADX.

  • But you probably didn't hear about it

  • because the government gagged family members and lawyers

  • from talking about it.

  • But here's the thing:

  • the American criminal justice system is supposed to be transparent.

  • And before someone gets sent to prison,

  • that's largely true.

  • Legislators meet in public to debate and define the laws

  • that prohibit criminal conduct.

  • Citizens in our community serve as jurors on criminal trials.

  • And if you want to watch a trial,

  • the courtroom doors are wide open.

  • After the trial, though, our commitment to transparency ends.

  • With the prison door securely shut,

  • what happens behind prison walls

  • stays behind prison walls.

  • And without the scrutiny of the public gaze,

  • the darkness festers.

  • Other than execution,

  • incarceration is the most intrusive power of the state:

  • the deprivation of citizens' liberty.

  • But no government institution

  • is more opaque and less accountable than prison.

  • Even though prisons are supported by tax payers

  • and return 95 percent of their residents to our communities.

  • It's that secrecy that allows the ADX to disappear people.

  • And so we have an obligation, said Justice Kennedy,

  • as a democracy and as a people,

  • "we should know what happens after the prisoner is taken away."

  • The prison system is the concern and responsibility of every citizen.

  • This is your justice system.

  • These are your prisons.

  • Torture happens in the dark.

  • And so we need to embrace the admonition that sunlight is the best disinfectant.

  • Not only because we need to know what happens inside ADX,

  • but because the knowing itself can create change.

  • There's an axiom in physics called the uncertainty principle.

  • It teaches that the mere fact of observation

  • can alter, will alter,

  • the subatomic reaction being observed.

  • In other words,

  • watching something affects its course.

  • In a democracy like the US,

  • prisons are administered in our name and on our behalf.

  • The conditions in ADX implicate our tax dollars,

  • public safety

  • and, most of all,

  • our shared belief in the inherent dignity of every human being.

  • We have an obligation to bear witness.

  • Thank you.

  • (Applause)

The drive through the world's most secure prison is beautiful.

字幕と単語

ワンタップで英和辞典検索 単語をクリックすると、意味が表示されます

B1 中級

TED】Laura Rovner.独房では人々に何が起こるのか (独房では人々に何が起こるのか|Laura Rovner) (【TED】Laura Rovner: What happens to people in solitary confinement (What happens to people in solitary confinement | Laura Rovner))

  • 104 1
    林宜悉 に公開 2021 年 01 月 14 日
動画の中の単語