Placeholder Image

字幕表 動画を再生する

  • Speaker 1: Why are cities across America considering bans on e-cigarettes and vaping? Is it to

  • protect public health? While that's what you typically hear, I think there's another important

  • explanation. After all, there are lots of unhealthy products that nobody's trying to

  • ban. One reason vaping, in particular, is being

  • targeted is due to lobbying from big businesses. Namely, tobacco companies. Hold on. Aren't

  • some of the people pushing for bans on e-cigarettes the same folks who used to lobby against big

  • tobacco? Absolutely. Many anti-tobacco activists have become anti-vaping

  • activists. Saying that just like regular cigarettes, e-cigarettes could be dangerous for people's

  • health or that they could send the wrong message to kids.

  • Now those activists find themselves on the same side as their formal foes since tobacco

  • company lobbyists are fighting e-cigarettes, too. They're worried about their bottom line.

  • Studies show that vaping is twice as effective as other methods in helping people quit smoking.

  • By pushing for regulations that make e-cigarettes less accessible to consumers they ensure that

  • more people will keep smoking tobacco. We've got a classic case of what some scholars call

  • the "Bootleggers and Baptists Phenomena." Well-intentioned activists end up pushing

  • for the same rules in the interests they actually oppose. This helps lend all the lobbying efforts

  • an air of legitimacy. They can claim it's for public health.

  • Meanwhile, most of the lobbying money is on the side interests that don't care about health.

  • They care about getting an unfair advantage over their competitors by using government

  • regulations to work in their favor. The tobacco company, RJ Reynolds, has even

  • hedged their bets by starting to make their own brands of e-cigarettes, while simultaneously

  • lobbying for bans against other types of e-cigarettes. The kinds they don't make. Claiming that those

  • kinds are a bigger health risk. Talk about an unfair advantage.

  • Unfortunately, situations like this are not uncommon. In every industry, you'll find businesses

  • that are using their money to lobby the government to get regulations passed that look like they're

  • in the public interest, but actually benefit them at the expense of their competitors.

  • Doesn't it seem wrong that these big businesses get to decide what you do with your body and

  • your property? Isn't that for you to decide? A better approach would be allowing individuals

  • and property owners to decide where e-cigarettes can be used ... not to enact regulations that

  • make it harder for smokers to quit.

Speaker 1: Why are cities across America considering bans on e-cigarettes and vaping? Is it to

字幕と単語

ワンタップで英和辞典検索 単語をクリックすると、意味が表示されます

B1 中級

公衆衛生。タバコ会社と禁煙 - 自由を学ぶ (Public Health: Tobacco Companies and Anti-Smoking - Learn Liberty)

  • 76 4
    Danny Wang に公開 2021 年 01 月 14 日
動画の中の単語