字幕表 動画を再生する
I've set things up so theories will continue to appear over the next three weeks. Just watch me theorists...
I'll make dinner with my right hand and write theories with my left. I'll take a potato chip and EAT IT.
I'll take my leftovers and REHEAT IT. I'll play Mario and BEAT IT.
I'll open the script for Doctor Who part three... *laughing*
-and COMPLETE IT. Well, maybe not that last one...
*Film Theory Intro* I love how you made this Mat.
Hello internet! Welcome to Film Theory.
So, here's a fun fact. When I'm at conventions, one of the most popular things
I'm asked to sign are people's recently purchased Death Notes.
It makes me wonder whether they're fans of the show or just haters who want to end the channel...
*ominous music* By any means necessary...
Either way, I'm totally in the clear since I don't take chances and sign with a misspelling of my name.
It's totally true! The paranoia is real!!
Seriously, if you have ever asked me to sign your Death Note, check it out.
Usually, what I do is I attach a little bit of extra text to the end where I'm like
"Ha, ha, This isn't how I actually spell my name."
Also, side note, apologies to any "Matt Pats" out there who spell their name with a double T.
Anyway, today we're talking about Death note since Netflix just released a live-action Death Note movie
and since I'm writing this episode before it comes out, let me just cover my bases here.
"Man, It was the worst! I mean, L in public, Light second-guessing himself,
I can't believe that they didn't stay true to the original anime!"
Or..
"Wow! It was so great, right? Ryuk was PERFECT and they nailed Misa's character."
Sorry, I hate to make you guys work like that
But I thank you for going the extra mile and inserting the appropriate of the two responses.
So let me just put this out there: I love, LOVE the original anime!
It's like 25 of the best written episodes ever put to a TV screen.
"But Matpat there are actually 37 episodes."
Like I said, 25 of the most tense, densely plotted episodes ever put to air.
For those of you unfamiliar, main character Light Yagami has it all;
the top grades in his class the attention of all his female
classmates and a magical notebook that has the ability to kill people when he writes their names in it. Okay.
So, one of those things is not quite like the others. Unlike most people who get kind of icky over the prospect of killing people
with the flick of a pen, Light sees this as his opportunity to
Purify the world of Evil. Taking out all the world's criminals and in the process becoming the vigilante known as Kira. And no,
That's not a racist way of saying killer. His name is actually Kira. Along the way,
He attracts copycat killers and plays an intense game of Cat-And-Mouse against the Brilliant deductive mind of a mysterious
Detective known only as L. It is without
Question my favorite anime. But as I get ready to watch the Netflix movie, it suddenly occurred to me
We spend so much time zoomed in on the personal conflicts between Light and L, that we as the audience
Lose sight the larger conflict here just how many killings are happening over the course of the series light has some epic montage
Sequences well about is that because you can get when the action consists of writing people's names down the entire point of these?
Montages is to illustrate the extent of these killing sprees
but when it comes to the question of how many
Names were actually written into the death note things kind of get blurry so today
I'm working to get the best estimate possible for how many lives like cut short during his reign as Kira now
I say estimate since most of his killing occurs off screen meaning we can never get a hundred percent accurate number that said though
We can get close if we know one the duration of time during which Kira's active and to the rate at which, Kira Kills
So number one how long does Kira kill for well?
It's a simple question that has a complicated answer you see for one thing
There are a total of four people who operate under the Kira alias at one point or another as light creates these
Complex Notebook handoffs and his attempt to evade capture making matters worse
Is that sometimes multiple Kira's are active at the same time with as many as three death notes at play?
Fortunately we have access to the complete time-stamped list of all the major events that happen throughout the series
Thanks to the handy time line that was printed in the bonus thirteenth volume of the manga and it bears mentioning that yes
This is a timeline covering the manga however it tells the exact same story as the anime only time shifted three years earlier because it
Came out first. They kept the months and days consistent from Manga to anime only changing the year by three years
So really the absolute time that Kira is active remains the same so now spoiler alert
I'm about to show you a timeline mapping out the whole series so go binge watch it, and then come back here seriously
It'll be a great weekend activity for you everyone back great and here
It is yep
It is a lot six years of killing spread across four main Kira's using three separate notebooks and a partridge in a pear tree
Add to that the police the mafia and hoo boy it is more confusing than light playing musical notebooks in the woods
But at this point
we have a solid idea of how long each of the kira's was an operation as expected light was the longest at
2030 three Total days Second Kira model and actress, Misa
Amane is only active for 60 seven days primarily because she was less interested in killing for justice and more interested in getting into lights
life Lights life Kyousuke-shi Gucci is Kira 3.0 active for
136 days and finally Tear Tomica me a devoted disciple of Tierra holds the note for the shortest amount of time only 61 days
But he's also the most enthusiastic
about it
Well, ho backspace on up there buddy because now that we know who had a death note and for how long we can calculate how
Many people each of them killed based on their rates of killing man if this video doesn't get flagged by YouTube's as being an advertiser
Unfriendly, it will be a miracle
So the key to estimating lights rate of killing lies in this first encounter with Ryu late shinigami or god of death when Ryo first
Appears we learned that lights been writing the names of criminals in the death note for five days several death notes
Have made their way into the human world in the past
But you're the first to a britain has many names look at how many people you killed in only five days
The show gives us a glimpse of his open notebook where we can observe that he writes names divided into four Columns and 39 Rows
each that's a total of
156 names per page that clip also shows us that lights already completed two full pages a total of three hundred and twelve names if
We take the lowball estimate and assume that light only has filled those two pages in the five days then the average
Comes out to sixty two point four names per day now realize that this is only an average light obviously isn't writing exactly
62 names every single day for instance there's one day where he kills exactly 24 criminals one every hour to make a very specific point?
To L and then on the days where he's under surveillance he probably kills fewer criminals
But we also know that light likes to cue up criminals to die even on days when he's not
diligently writing names in his death note
So what matters here is the average not the exact he writes down on any given day so that?
62.4 is a good baseline then comes the five year intermission after light defeats L, during which light is acting completely
Uncontested assuming the role of Kyra and knight and the role of the new L
During the day and as he can imagine since he's a serial killer leading a task force out to catch him
He's not too good at his day job during this period A narrator tells us that the Kira killings accelerate in the summer according to
his killings increased at an unprecedented rate its first five days as Kira are a pretty good representation of what an
Unimpeded Kira looks like he comes from from school does his homework and then spends the rest of his free time
Writing names in his notebook like a lovesick middle schooler when like two feet zell
He still has to perform his day job with the police task force and at night Misa is also distracting him wink wink
Don't you hate it when the blonde actress slash model who adores everything that you do pulls you away from your nightly killing spree
So let's assume that the rate of his killings during this period Doubles per day
It's nothing too extreme just an extra 60 or so names at night because he has misa helping him do research running those numbers across
This two thousand Thirty three days as Kira gives us two hundred and forty two
Thousand one hundred and Twelve names in the book hold up two hundred and forty two
thousand approximately sixty two names per day times 365 days
Doubling for when L is defeated and run back for five years yeah that number checks out
And that's a conservative estimate think about that two hundred thousand names
That's more than the populations of forty seven separate countries in fact near the end of the series near yeah
His name is actually near calls the death note the deadliest weapon of Mass murder in the history of Mankind
That's a pretty tall order, but when you actually look at the numbers. It's true the third death note alone
The one light yagami used during his five years
uncontested killed more people than the atomic bomb dropped on hiroshima at the end of world war two which was itself the
Single deadliest attack in recorded history in the end. You're nothing more than a crazy serial killer
No, light is much more dangerous the term serial killer specifically excludes war crimes and government sanctioned killings and by that definition
Kira comes out on top by A
huge Margin some of the deadliest serial killers in recorded history Luis Guerra Beto and pedro Lopez have fewer than
200 known victims while Kira's number in the hundreds of thousands even the deadliest conventional serial killers are around only
One-tenth of one percent as deadly as Kira, and that is just light
We still have three other kilos uh Kira's
To discuss mises number is just a drop in the bucket compared to lights killing spree only around
400 she had a short run and only killed for attention any killings that she does do during that five year intermission period Are more
For helping out lights total because he's the type of person who wouldn't allow that power to anyone else
He probably wants to save her all that writing to himself and as we see during the montage for that segment
They're both on computers together researching
But he's the only one that we ever see writing names when the audience learns that Gucci is the third Kira
We see his notebook laid out on the table
And it shows that he's written a total of 64 names 16 rows across four columns if that's what's in a day's work for
Higuchi
Then that would make his daily body count almost
Exactly the same as what we calculated for light earlier an average of 64 names per day times
136 Days works out to eight thousand seven hundred and four people dead at a Higuchi's hands. And lastly taro Myka me out of all
The Kira's Mikami holds his death note for the fewest number of days
But he fills in one page per day. That might not sound like much,
but one page for Mikami is serious business. With over six columns and
Seventy-six Rows per page Mikami is executing a whopping
456 people every Single Day
I'm not sure what's more Impressive?
the number of names that mikami manages to write every day or that he manages to squeeze them all in there?
Maybe might not be the brightest when it comes to executing light's strategy,
but you've got to give this guy points for penmanship! With a total of 61 active days mikami's total kill count tallies in at
27,816!
27,000 people in two months! So to recap our tallies are Light Yagami, 242,112
Misa Amane, 392
Kyosuke Higuchi, 8704
And Teru Mikami, 27,816
adding up to just under 280,000
total victims
280,000 people dead!
To give you a point of comparison, that is just shy of the
300,000 Americans who died during World War one.
The only wars to kill more U.S soldiers were world war one, two, and the Civil war
And remember, this estimate is a conservative number we don't see proof of it
but misa could absolutely be more active during that five year intermission if light allowed her to be
And light himself could definitely be more aggressive in his writing
if he wanted to be. For an even better comparison of the vastness of the number of people these guys are killing, consider this.
When we see lights notebook open, Yes
We see some western names
But there's also a few names written in
Japanese. This makes total sense since the series is set in Japan and lights first language is Japanese
So it would just be an easier place for him to Target
In 2009 Japan's Prison population was seventy five thousand two hundred fifty.
Just a fourth of Kira's Total kill count in other words during his six years
He could have exterminated Japan's entire prison population and still had time to deal with the rest of the world's criminals
that said the U.S has a
Few more people in prison. Two million two hundred seventy thousand to be exact so even if Kira's efforts were entirely
Concentrated on the U.S, It would have only been around thirteen percent of the total us prison population
Furthermore worldwide there are eight hundred and seventy four thousand one hundred people murdered last year
Holy Jeez that's a huge number
So even if Kira only targeted murders his total number of killings over six years
Would only be thirty two percent of the total number of murders in one year. Ho Boy
Hide your kids, hide your wives. Hide your kids, hide your wives.
The world is kind of a scary place sometimes.
And I gotta be honest. Light, for all his purging the world talk, made it a bit
Scarier. You see, even though he sees himself as the embodiment of justice..
I am..
I am..
Justice!
He kills innocents along the way in order to stay out of prison
Raye Penber, Raye's fiancee, 11 FBI agents that were sent to investigate him,
L, Watari, then of course the killings that were done by the other Kiras!
Light justifies these deaths as
Necessary in his quest to bring peace to the world,
And in truth, those people make up only 1/10 of 1% of Kira's total death toll
But is he right in this assessment?When we say that Kira killed
279,024 criminals, that's under the assumption that all of those people were guilty!
But what light doesn't take into account, are false convictions. Which happen more frequently than you might think. According to the national registry of exonerations,
The number of Prisoners being released as their crimes are disproven has been increasing since
2011 a rate of 3 exonerations per week. Other criminal Justice studies have shown that in the U.S.
specifically as many as 4 point 1 percent of death row inmates in the us might be innocent. And that's only in the U.S, and
Only for people who've been convicted. We know that in some cases, Kira
Simply Targets suspects. If four percent of the people Kira sends to death would have later been exonerated that means Kira has killed over
11,000 innocent victims. Not quite the drop in the bucket that light seems to think it is there's also plenty of other issues that exist
In the criminal justice system. For example in the U.S,
94 percent of all cases are decided by Plea bargains. Where people confess guilt to a lesser crime to avoid the risk of being convicted
Of something more serious, even if they're not guilty at all!
They just don't want to run the risk or waste the time in trial
Some estimates put the number of Innocents who are currently serving prison time due to plea bargains at around
20,000 and Japan has a BIG problem with wrongful convictions. Suspects arrested for questioning can be held up to
23 days during which the suspect isn't allowed to have contact with an attorney
There's even one case where a prosecutor threatened to kill a suspect during his interrogation
Japan's conviction Rate is, get this...
99.8%!!!
Let me make this easy for you. If you're in court in a japanese courtroom,
You are going to prison.
Just stop wasting your time get started on your prison sentence and get it over with faster
It's a system where guilty until proven innocent really prevails. And in Kira's eyes,
They're all guilty, regardless of the evidence! By the end of the series people and governments
just send him names! With light killing hundreds of thousands of people, you think he's got time to check each and every one?
So whats the upshot here? Is Kira Truly justice?
well
Let me give you the numbers and you can go debate it in the comments. Near the end of the anime we find out that
By the end of Kira's six year reign the world's violent crime rate has fallen by 70%
Since Kiras appearance six years ago, wars have stopped. And global crime rates have been reduced by over 70 percent
A 70% decrease in the number of Worldwide Murders would Decrease the number of killings in a given year
By 611,870. So by killing an average of
46,500 people per year, around two thousand of those being innocent, Kira prevented over six hundred thousand murders
Every single year, and that's not even mentioning all the other violent crime that went down
This is the Dilemma of Death Note.
Light is clearly, clearly a villain saying he's driven by a better world when in actuality his ego and lust for power are his true driving
Motivations and yet, you can't deny, He got results
So was he right all along? The show provides No clear answers and remember, it's all just fiction
But it raises a great debate a debate that hopefully I was able to help you out with by providing more accurate numbers
So you can assess the situation and although I can't answer any of those questions definitively for you
I can at least present you with one final and slightly lighter question related to death note
Could Kira kill Goku?
Spoiler alert the answer is obviously yes
but go ahead! Debate it in the comments 'cuz remember it's all just a theory! A film theory! aanndd
cut
Pretty good video, huh?
I really enjoyed it
So.... umm....
You could check out some more of his videos right there...
Or subscribe..
Well the videos ending now so ill see you later.