字幕表 動画を再生する
-
Hey, everyone. I'm Alex.
-
Thanks for clicking, and welcome to this lesson on "Who" vs. "Whom".
-
That's right, today we are going to look at one of the most commonly confused and asked
-
about subjects in the English language, not just by new English learners but native speakers
-
as well.
-
So, we're going to use some grammar terminology, but I'm also going to give you some examples
-
that will make it very clear what the difference between these two words is.
-
So, first I'm going to talk about how to use them in statements, and after I'm going to
-
show you how to use them with quantifiers, and at the end I'll look at some question
-
examples with these two.
-
So, let's start.
-
First: "who" and "whom".
-
These are relative pronouns.
-
Now, what this means is "who" is a subject relative pronoun, "whom" is an object relative pronoun.
-
What does this mean?
-
Well, this means that when you use "who" in a sentence to give more information about
-
something, you are using it to give more information about a subject.
-
When you use "whom", you're using it to give more information about the object of a sentence.
-
So let's look at some examples first with "who".
-
Number one: "I have an uncle who works for Apple."
-
Number two: "There's someone who is waiting for you."
-
Number three: "Tom, who's been working here forever, recently found a new job."
-
What do they all have in common?
-
Well, they all have a subject, a person who you're giving more information about.
-
So, I'm going to mark things up a little bit so you can see how this works.
-
"I have an uncle who works for Apple."
-
Who are you giving more information about in this sentence?
-
You are giving more information about your uncle.
-
So you have "who", and "who" relates to an uncle.
-
Now, this uncle is doing an action.
-
The uncle works for Apple.
-
So, if you have a subject, you're giving more information about the subject, and the subject
-
is doing an action after who, then you use "who".
-
All right?
-
"I have an uncle who works", he works for Apple.
-
Next: "There is someone who is waiting for you."
-
So we have "who".
-
Who does "who" relate to?
-
"Who" relates to "someone", a mystery person.
-
So there's someone who is waiting for you.
-
Yes, we are giving more information about someone, and the someone is doing an action.
-
So here they are waiting.
-
So I have someone...
-
There is someone who is waiting.
-
They are the ones who are doing the action.
-
Next: "Tom, who's been working here forever, recently found a new job."
-
So we have "who", I'm just going to mark "who's", "who has" been working.
-
And yes, we are talking about Tom.
-
And we are saying that Tom has been working here.
-
So if the subject of the sentence is doing the action here, then you need to use "who".
-
Next: "whom".
-
Three sentences.
-
One: "Ghandi is someone whom most people admire."
-
Two: "That's the guy whom she married."
-
Three: "My best friend, whom I've known for 10 years, is getting married."
-
So, what's the difference between these sentences and the sentences with "who"?
-
Hmm.
-
"Ghandi is someone whom most people admire."
-
Yes, the sentence is about Ghandi.
-
We are talking about Ghandi in this sentence.
-
But also important: Is Ghandi doing an action in this sentence or is he receiving an action
-
in this sentence?
-
Here we have: "Ghandi is someone whom most people admire."
-
The sentence is actually talking about the people who admire Ghandi.
-
The people are doing an action to Ghandi,
-
and Ghandi is receiving the action in this sentence.
-
So, here, and this is true in most cases, after "whom" you usually have someone who
-
does the action to someone else.
-
So: "Ghandi is someone whom most people admire."
-
Next: "That's the guy whom she married."
-
We see "whom".
-
Who does "whom" relate to?
-
Yes, we are talking about the guy, but the guy is receiving the action.
-
He's actually an object here, because she married him.
-
Now, I don't mean that the man is an object and the woman is the...
-
An object in many cases, so I don't mean any of that.
-
But grammatically, that's the guy whom she married.
-
The guy is receiving the action of marriage from her.
-
And finally: "My best friend, whom I have known for 10 years, is getting married."
-
Here we have "whom".
-
Who are we talking about?
-
Okay, my best friend, yeah.
-
But my best friend is receiving an action here.
-
I have known my best friend.
-
Okay?
-
So here, I'm saying I have known my best friend.
-
I have known him or her.
-
Okay?
-
So if this person that you want to talk about is receiving some kind of action, like:
-
"Ghandi is someone whom most people admire.",
-
"That's the guy whom she married.",
-
"My best friend, whom I've known for 10 years, is getting married."
-
If you have these cases you must use "whom".
-
A very easy trick, quick and easy to remember: In most cases, when you use "who" you're going
-
to use a verb after it.
-
Okay?
-
So: "He's someone who works all the time.", "They are a couple who is very happy."
-
And "whom" most of the time you are going to have a pronoun, a person, someone's name
-
after it.
-
So: "He is someone whom many people respect."
-
Or: "She's someone whom I love."
-
Now, I say most cases because in the passive voice you could also say:
-
"Ghandi is someone whom is admired."
-
And obviously we're saying by many people in this situation.
-
Okay, I'm going to go to the next room and we're going to look at quantifiers with "who"
-
or "whom", and we're going to look at questions with "who" or "whom".
-
Come with me.
-
Oh, you guys are already here.
-
Perfect.
-
All right, so next we're going to talk about "who" and "whom" with quantifiers.
-
Now, don't let the word "quantifiers" scare you.
-
Quantifiers just mean words that talk about quantity, like "many"; or numbers like "one",
-
"two", "three", "four", "five"; or "some; or "most; or "20%".
-
It can be anything that involves numbers, and quantity, and size.
-
Okay?
-
So, here I have two sentences.
-
First: "My students, most of whom are from Brazil, have a test today."
-
Next: "There are 20 people at the party, 16 of whom I know."
-
Now, here: "most of whom are from Brazil", "16 of whom I know",
-
these are actually adjective clauses that include quantifiers in them,
-
an expression of quantity.
-
And first thing I want to do is explain the formula to you.
-
So when you use this construction, you need your subject, you need a subject like:
-
"my students" or "20 people at the party".
-
So, after that you need quantifier.
-
For quantifier, I'm just going to put "q" plus "of" plus "whom" plus other info.
-
I'm just going to put "other info".
-
So it's always: "most of whom", "some of whom",
-
"three of whom", "two of whom", "30% of whom",
-
and you'll also notice I'm always saying: "whom", "whom", "whom", "whom".
-
This is one case where you always have to say "whom".
-
Okay?
-
You cannot say: "Most of who".
-
It's always: "Most of whom", "three of whom", etc.
-
So, let's look at these one more time.
-
"My students, most of whom are from Brazil, have a test today."
-
They have a test today.
-
And next: "There are 20 people at the party, 16 of whom I know."
-
So I know 16 people at the party, and the party has 20 people.
-
So just remember when you have this construction you need to use "whom".
-
And there is actually a lesson on this on my engVid channel, so you can check that out,
-
too, if you want more detailed explanation.
-
And finally, questions.
-
Now, questions are tricky...
-
And all of this is tricky actually, but questions in particular because very few people, especially
-
native speakers use "whom" in a question form, most of the time because they don't know the rule.
-
And the rule is followed in the same way like I explained at the beginning where "who" is
-
subject relative, "whom" is object relative.
-
So, I have four questions.
-
Let's look at the first one.
-
"Who saw the accident?"
-
These are all correct, by the way.
-
There are no mistakes in these questions.
-
"Who saw the accident?"
-
You're asking a question about: Who saw?
-
Who did the action of seeing?
-
So here it's obvious you must use "who" because the who, let's say his name is Marcus, and
-
I say: "Marcus saw the accident. Marcus is the person who saw the accident."
-
He did the action, so in the question: Who did the action?
-
Who saw the accident?
-
Next: "Whom did she pick for the job?"
-
Now, here, we have to use "whom" because she, the boss, is picking them.
-
Okay?
-
So if I say: "She picked Jack", and Jack is the person who got the job.
-
Okay, Jack is the one whom she picked.
-
She picked him.
-
So here, again, we don't know whom she picked.
-
She did the action to this person.
-
So: "Whom did she pick for the job?"
-
Next: "Do you know who won last night?"
-
So I'm watching a soccer game, I'm watching a hockey game, and you know, I watched it,
-
my friend did not watch it.
-
And he says: "Hey. You saw the game last night.
-
Do you know who won?"
-
So here, obviously, the team who won is the team who did the action of scoring and winning.
-
So we have to use "who".
-
And finally: "Do you know whom she was talking about?"
-
So she was talking about someone else.
-
We don't know who, and again, the correct way to say it is in this situation:
-
"whom she was talking about", because she is giving us more information.
-
We don't know whom she did the action of talking about to.
-
I'm sorry, that's very complex.
-
So, honestly, guys, in most cases most native speakers just say "who", especially in questions.
-
So if you say "who" and you're a new English learner, do not worry because almost no one
-
will know that you are making a mistake.
-
And even though it is technically a grammar mistake, it's so commonly used and accepted
-
that it's not really a mistake.
-
As a grammar teacher, I'm telling you that.
-
What's more important, the fact that you speak correct English or the fact that you speak
-
English that other people are using all around you and you want to interact with those people?
-
Both are important, correct English, but it's more important that you are using the English
-
that native speakers are using.
-
Whew.
-
So that's a lot of information today, and I hope that I was able to erase some of your
-
doubts, some of your confusion about this very complex topic.
-
And if you want to test your understanding, and if you want to know for sure that you
-
know the difference between "who" and "whom", as always, you can check out the quiz on www.engvid.com.
-
And if you liked this video,
-
don't forget to comment on it, like it, subscribe to the channel, and check me out on Facebook and Twitter.
-
I've got a lot of stuff on there, pictures of me with lightsabers and stuff like that,
-
so maybe you'll like that.
-
And if you want to support engVid, don't forget to donate to the site.
-
Til next time, thanks for clicking, and I will see you later.
-
Bye.