字幕表 動画を再生する
This video sparked an online viral storm
about the new iPhone 6 smartphones And how they bend under pressure
From there, #bendgate took off on social media with people bending their phones
Blaming tight pants and spoofing the whole story
Consumer Reports wanted to bring some science to the matter
And find out how much force does it take
For a phone to bend and not bend back
So we took 6 smartphones, including the new iPhones, into our lab for stress testing
We used what's called an Instron compression test machine. Right behind me.
We started at 10 pounds of force for 30 seconds, then release
The we upped the force in 10 pound increments and noted it when the phone first began to deform
Our test lineup, the iPhone 6 Plus, obviously
Along with its comfortably sized competitors, the Samsung Galaxy Note 3 and the LG G3
We also tested the smaller iPhone 6 along with the HTC One M8
For apple fans still holding on their iPhone 5, we put that one in, too.
We tested 1 sample of each. Turns out,
it takes a lot of force to permanently bend one of these new iPhones
And all the other phones we tested for that matter
Even the phones that bent first, the iPhone 6 and HTC One took 70lbs of force before bending permanently
The iPhone 6 Plus took more punishment at 90 lbs
But the smaller, thicker precursor, the iPhone 5 outperformed both of siblings at our test
The no noticeable deformation until 130 lbs of force
Finally, there was the LG G3 and Samsung Galaxy Note 3
which sprang back to form up until we applied 130 lbs and 150 lbs respectably
At that point, their screens separated from their cases and stopped working
For comparison, we put a few pencils in the Intron
It took 80 pounds of force to break 4
I've got 4 right hereI've got 4 right here. And I can tell you, that's pretty tough
Alright, maybe 3
And this is what 100 lbs of force look like on a tennis ball, fresh out of the can
One note, a bent phone is bad, but can still function
All the iPhones and HTC One looked beat up after our initial test, but were still working
So we went further to see how much more they could take. As we moved beyond 90 lbs of force
Screens on those phones started separating from their cases
The iPhone 5 held up the longest of these 4, maxing out at 150 lbs of force
Apple's official response is
"With normal use, a bend in iPhone is extremely rare and through our first six days of sale, "
"a total of nine customers have contacted Apple with a bent iPhone 6 Plus"
So what's the bottom line for bendgate? Well, based on our comparative here at Consumer Reports
While not the strongest phones on the market, fear of a serious structural design flaw in the iPhone 6 and 6 Plus seem overblown
Follow our ongoing coverage of the new iPhone 6's and all of our electronic reviews
at consumerreports.org