Itwasreallysimple. Inmyparticularcase I concluded I wasbadatlanguagesaftermySpanishexperienceinthefewyearspriortothatbecauselikeeveryone,
well I shouldn't sayeveryonebutmostpeoplewhogothroughthenormalformalschoolingapproachcouldn't stringmorethan a fewsentencestogether,
certainlycouldn't have a conversationand I endedupswitchingtoJapanesewhen I switchedschoolsand I hadtheopportunitytostudyotherlanguages
andmythoughtwaswell I amgoingtobebadatlanguagesnomatterwhichone I choose I mightaswell, numberonestudysomethingrelatedto a culturethat I amfascinatedby,
soNinjasandallthatstuff, SamuraiandwhathaveyouandsecondlymyfriendswereinandoneortwoofmynewfriendsatthatschoolwereintheJapaneseclass, so I jumpedintoJapanese.
therewassomethingreallyunusualaboutitbutsecondly I gaveupontryingtomimicwhat I doneinschoolbecauseitwasn't working.
When I wenttoSaiki I rememberthefirstdayofclassesso I hadbeenmeasuredformyschooluniform
I lookedlike a WestPointcadetandwentintotheEnglishdepartmentofficebecause I wasbasicallytheirpetfortheyear
andthisguycameuptomeandhegoesyouknowandhegivesmethispaperand I couldn't...
I waslikesorry I can't readthiswhatdoesitsayandheislikeok, ok
traditionalJapanese [Japanese] physicsokandreadthroughthewholelistand I wasjustpuzzledbythisanditturnedoutthatwhat I hadbeentoldbefore
I wentbecause I wasverynervoushesaiddon't worryyouwillhaveplentyofJapaneseclassesandlostintranslationwasthattheywereallregularhighschoolJapaneseclasses,
so I wenttobookstoresand I boughtwhat I thoughtappearedtobeJapanesetextbookslikemySpanishtextbookshadbeen
anditjustdidn't workattheendoftheday, whether I wasboredbythematerialorthebooksthemselveswere a problemintheprogression,
eitherwayitdidn't workandaroundthesixmonthpointiswhen I reallyembracedjudotextbooksandcomicbooksand I foundthatthejudotextbooks
because I wasinterestedinthesubjectmattergavemethegrammarbecausethegrammartransfersofcoursebetweensubjectmatter
and I actuallythinkelectricalengineeringwouldbereallygoodtrainingforlanguagesbutatleastasgoodasanEastAsianstudiesdegree
butwecancomeoutwiththecomicso I have a littleshowandtell,
thecomicbooksturnedinto a realoutletformebecauseit's alldialogueit's almostalldialogueandnotonlyisitalmostalldialoguebutitdoesn't trytobe,
itdoesnotattempttobeformalthereissomeformalitybutit's mostlyveryinformalsofor a highschoolkidthatwasperfect.
Sohereisoneexamplethisis "onepiece" I have... thecoversarethesamesoonce I didthatinJapanese
thisisonepieceinGermanandonepieceinSpanishandit's a verypopularseriesasyoucangetitineverylanguage
Sothatwas a bigbreakthroughpointand I thinkthatmuchlikephysicaladaptationforsportsthereis a neuroplasticityaspectthatdoestaketime
andtherearewaystocompressitbutinmycasewithJapaneseiswasbetweenthatsixandeightmonthpointwheretherewas a realinflexionpointandthat's prettymuchhowitturnedout.
Yeahandformeitwasmostly a mentalityshiftbecause I thinkthosesixmonthsweren't necessarilyhelpingmewhen I waslearningSpanish
butsomething I amsureyouhavewrittenaboutthis, oneofthemajorissuesinlanguagesisin a traditionaleducationpeoplelookat a nativespeaker
andthatiskindofthegoalandthepresumptionislet's sayforexamplethatmastering a language a hundredpercenttosoundlike a native,
let's sayittakes 15 years I mean I don't knowhowlongittakes, let's sayittakesthat
andthentheykindofthinklogicallyithastotake 15 yearssotogetfiftypercentofthatyouwouldneedsevenand a halfyears?
butasyouaddwordsthereis a dramaticpointofdiminishingreturns, manypointsofdiminishingreturnssoifyouwantedtoget...
theexplanationthat I sometimesgivetopeopleisifyouwantedtofool a nativespeakerintothinkingthatyouareclosetonativeorperhapsgrewupthere,
let's say 30 daysoutof a 30 daycalendarmonththatmighttake 10 years,
itmightlikeyousaid I don't knowmaybebuttogettothepointwhereyoucandoit 29 daysoutof 30
I thinkyoucoulddothatin a yearorlesswithouttoomuchtroubleifyoureallyapplyyourself.
Butit's gettingthosefinalgrainsofsalt, thosefinalwordsthatreallyrequiresthathugeinvestmentorsoitwouldseembutyeahthatis a goodpoint I thinkthemathematical...
whenyourunthementalarithmeticanddistributeitacross 15 years, ohwellif I wantedtobeeven 50% isgoodwhichinmostpeople's mindsisprettycrappystill,
itwilltakesevenandhalfyears I amnotevengoingtotrylikethatisthewayit's...yeahthat's a goodpoint I haveneverputitthatway.
Yeahbecauselikewhat I foundiswhen I amtryingtolearn a languagesomethingsimilartotheParatoprinciple
youtalkabout a lotis I ammuchmorefocussedontheshorttermandwhatcan I dointheshortterm
and I thinkthisisveryverydifferenttotraditionalmethodsthatkindofseeanythinglessthanmasteryof a languageas a wasteoftimeanduseless
and I meanrealisticallyyeahitwouldbegreatifeveryonethought I was I native 100% ofthetimebut I meanwhydo I reallyneedthat,
what I amlookingforis I wanttohavegoodconversationswithpeople, I don't wanttheretobeanymisunderstandingsand I haveactuallyreachedthestage
where I canpassfor a nativespeakerinparticularsituationsforyouknowuptotwominutes
andthereis a lotofrestrictionstherelike I havetobein a situationthat I amcomfortableinandsoon
andso I can't sayyouknowyouaregoingtoconfusemefor a nativeallthetimebuttheseareallrealisticthingsifyoulookatwhatyouwanttoworkon
andyouknowpeoplecancomeupwithsillythingslikeyouhavetobeabletodebateKantianphilosophyand I amlikeyouknow I don't dothatinEnglish,
yetyouhavetolikemystandardsforfluencyarebasedonwhat I candoinEnglishandwhenpeoplestartsayingyouknowyouhavegottobeabletotalkpolitics,
I amlike I findpoliticsboringyouknowifyoutalktomeinEnglishaboutpolitics I amnotgoingtobeabletodothat.
Solikeinmyunderstandingwhen I say I trytobe "fluent" in a language I aimingtobesociallyequivalenttohow I aminEnglish
so I canfollowmanypeoplespeakingamongstoneandother, I cantalktothemwithoutslowingtheconversationdown,
youknowit's asgoodasspeakingto a nativeeventhoughyouknow I amnot a nativebecause I ammaking a fewmistakes
andformethat's fluencyandthen a littlebithigherthanthatwouldbedoingthesethingsinprofessionalcontexts,
so I haveactuallysattheSpanishDELEthe C2 Diplomawhichistheprofessionallevel
but I stillthinkbelowthatit's stillveryverypowerfulandformeitcountsasfluency,
it's what I aimingforwhat I thinkisrealisticinthreemonthsisthissocialfluency.
Sooneofthebigquestionspeoplewereaskingmewhen I toldthem I wasgoingtotalktoyou,
ishowdoyoudefinefluentbecausein a laymen's contextit's veryeasytothrowthesewordsaround
likeyouknow I learnedhowtospeakSpanishinsomanyweeks, I meanwhatdoesthatevenmeanyouknow?
So I likeyoursocialequivalencyexplanationappliedbythatbuttheexamplethat I use,
likewheninalmosteverylanguagewhenyourunthrough a typicaltrainingprogramforbusybusinesspeople...
Yeah.
Alrightlet's learntoreadthefinancialtimes, if I grabthefinancialtimesonanairplane I can't readthedamnthinginEnglish
and I nevergoingtotalkaboutitcertainlybutthatis a wholeseparategripesession,
soforfluencyformepersonallymymarkerhasbeencan I havesay a 10 or 15 minuteconversationwithoutslowingdowntheconversation
where I canexpressanyidea I wanttoexpressandif I don't understandsomethingimmediatelyclarifyit,
soit's reallyhavinglike a 10 minutepleasantconversationwheretheotherpersonwouldcomeawaysayinglikeyes,
Insomecases I amaimingforsomethinglikewhen I wasinGerman I wasattheHochfachschule
whichisactually a prettygoodschooland I wasaimingforthatMittelstufe
andatfirstandthenmovingbeyondthatandthenwhen I wasinArgentina I likehavingconcreteobjectivegoals I thinkit's helpful,
noteveryoneneedsitbut I liketowherewithSpanish I wasaimingfor,
I guessitwaslikeNivelAvanzadointheUniversityofBuenosAiresbutjust a sidenotrealfastbecausetalkaboutmentalshift
I thinkpartofthereasonthatpeoplefailinlanguagesisthesamereasonthattheyfailatmanythingslikedieting,
thinkofdietinglikeokthisis a permanentchangeforeverhowdo I feelandit's overwhelming. Andsowithdietingit's a twoweektrial,
just a twoweektrialifyoudon't likeityoucanstop, andwithlanguages I thinkforinstance I nevertackleanylanguagethinkingthisisgoingtobe a lifelongprojectever,
I don't evertackle a languagethinkingthisisgoingtobe a oneyearproject,
everwhen I tackle a languageif I gotolet's sayTurkeyand I studyTurkish I don't expecttoeveruseTurkishagainafterthattrip
butbecauseevenhaving 20 phrasesmakesthattriptentimesmoreenjoyableand I learntentimesmore I willputinthetimeandthatishow...
youknowJapaneseanotherreasonJapanesecameoutis I hadanexchangestudentatmyhousewithmyfamilyandsowealllearnedfivetotensentencesofJapaneseandwegotalongreallywell.
That's actuallyexactlythesamereason I gotintoSpanishbecausewehostedSpanishstudentsinmyhometowninIreland.
Rightandforinstancewhen I wasinGalway, thisishystericalsowhen I wasinGalway,
I amnotsure I wroteaboutthis I studiedIrishandpeoplethinkJapaneseishard I wouldsayIrishjustduetothelackofmaterials
andalsoifyouwanttopracticewithanyonebecauseitwasfunnybecauseveryIrishperson I wouldmeet
theywouldgowhatareyoudoinghereand I wouldbelike I amdoing a hurlingandtheywouldbelikethat's weird
andthen I wouldsayIrishandtheywouldgowhatthehellareyoustudyingIrishforandyouwouldhavetogotolikeSpiddaldownintheGaeltachtandohman...
Yeah, yeahwellyouwouldactuallybesurprised I didreadyourmentionthisontheblogthatyouwouldconsiderIrishmoredifficult,
I thinkintermsofmaterialstocomeacrossyesyouaregoingtofind a lotlessbut I know a lotofpeoplewhohaveactuallylearneditat a distanceand I don't thinkit's necessarily,
I meancomparingittootherEuropeanlanguagesit's notthatintimidatingandespeciallybecausewearelessusedtoforeignerslearningit,