Placeholder Image

字幕表 動画を再生する

  • The best thing we can hope for is not to be understood

  • but to be misunderstood by original minds.

  • I remember the first poem I wrote, I was in like 6th grade.

  • I think I had 15 or 20 journal entries to the next day for school.

  • Like all great epiphanies,

  • I was trying to get out of doing something;

  • like all business people I know,

  • I was trying to do the least amount of work,

  • and still get credit for it.

  • So I wrote poems, and here is one of the poems I wrote that night:

  • "Why do we mow our lawns"

  • "It started to thunder I began to wonder

  • Why do we mow our lawns?

  • Then it hit me That nice lawns are pretty

  • When they wake up freshly cut at dawn.

  • Maybe they want to keep growing

  • But man’s too ignorant to stop mowing, So lawns are cut each day.

  • Because man doesn’t care About cutting nature’s hair,

  • Even if nature doesn’t want it that way."

  • Thank you!

  • (Laughter)

  • Well, the next night, my mom gets a phone call

  • from the school guidance counselor,

  • "Mrs. Martin, we are concerned that

  • your son Ross may be suicidal."

  • (Laughter)

  • I was a 6th grade kid

  • writing a poem about mowing the lawn!

  • Creative interpretation,

  • one of the great unheralded fountains of genius

  • and the best thing about it

  • it's so easy you can misunderstand anything,

  • whether we're crafting a poem,

  • or a TEDTalk, or a deli sandwich,

  • chances are our work will not be received

  • exactly as we intended.

  • That's a scary thing,

  • but it's also a great thing.

  • Whether we are talking about writing poems,

  • one of the oldest forms of art,

  • or social media, one of the newest,

  • most people would argue that a degree in poetry

  • prepares you for one thing:

  • living at home in your parents' basement,

  • eating pepperoni pizza and drinking beer out of a bag --

  • at best, maybe a side gig teaching poetry.

  • (Laughter)

  • But it was surprisingly great preparation

  • for my life as an executive in media.

  • The job of a poet is to --

  • I'm waiting for the laugh, because it's Snooki --

  • Ok, the job of a poet is to find truth in beauty,

  • To preserve the order of perception,

  • and by that I mean our own experience of things,

  • and to create experiences that other people can feel.

  • What if CMOs of big companies approached their jobs

  • a little more like that?

  • Now, we would never send crack teams of poets in

  • to reengineer businesses.

  • But you'd be surprised at how similar

  • the worlds of poetry and, let's say, media actually are.

  • Let's take the rules of a sonnet:

  • sonnets are 14 lines long,

  • they are in iambic pentameter,

  • da DA da DA da DA da DA da DA.

  • Sonnets have pretty rigorous form of rhyme schemes,

  • a-b-b-a or a-b-a-b,

  • and you can bet somewhere in there

  • there will be a metaphor about a rose.

  • What about television? Not so dissimilar.

  • An hour of television is actually 44 minutes of real show,

  • the rest, as you know, promo time and paid commercial time.

  • Those commercials have to be 60 seconds,

  • 30 seconds or 15 seconds,

  • and you can bet somewhere in the hour

  • there'll be a love triangle.

  • How does a poem end?

  • Well, the sonnet ends with an oral cue,

  • a heads-up from the poet, a rhymed couplet,

  • "Hey, I'm about to wrap this up, pay attention"

  • So, "Sonnet 130" from Shakespeare:

  • "So long as men can breathe, or eyes can see,

  • So long lives this, and this gives life to thee."

  • How does a TV show end?

  • Well, close up on an emotion,

  • on a character's face, the protagonist,

  • begin to pull back as the music swells,

  • and we pull back to wide shot of,

  • let's say, the Jersey shore.

  • (Laughter)

  • Well, things are a little different, right?

  • A hit can be a 30-minute show,

  • an hour can be a 3-minute video, a 30-second clip,

  • or even the 3-second look on the face of an adorable grasshopper.

  • But what does it sound like?

  • It sounds like free verse: E.E. Cummings knew that.

  • Over a century ago, poetry began

  • to break out of its rigorous formal constraints.

  • Now, if you are crafting a poem, or a TV show,

  • or a bar of soap,

  • we are all struggling to do the same thing,

  • we are struggling to translate an original creative impulse

  • into some sort of a formal output,

  • and no matter what, it goes on some sort of a shelf;

  • and when it gets there,

  • we really have no idea how it will be received.

  • In Graduate School,

  • my Pulitzer Prize-winning poet professor Yusef Komunyakaa

  • had us come in the first day and he said,

  • "We are going to go around,

  • you each are going to read a poem,

  • and then the class is going to critique it."

  • And I was psyched

  • because I had a really good poem in my pocket,

  • and I whipped it out, and he goes, "Ross, you go first,"

  • so I read my poem.

  • Silence, total silence, for painful minutes,

  • before, eventually, a classmate of mine

  • stood up and said, "That's not a poem".

  • (Laughter)

  • People will never receive your work exactly as you intended,

  • but the truth is we don't want them to,

  • we want them to chew it up, swallow it or reject it,

  • we want it to change them, and them to change it,

  • we want them to spit something back out

  • that's new and original;

  • or, at least, we better want that,

  • because we don't really have a choice.

  • My poetry professor in College was Olga Broumas,

  • this beautiful Greek Sapphic poet,

  • who would float around campus as if she was on air.

  • What Olga was teaching us to do

  • was to preserve the order of perception,

  • to let go and break free

  • of that nebulous chase for the real meaning of things,

  • and, instead, honour our own interpretation.

  • So, we'd come to class,

  • she'd ask us to read our new poem out loud,

  • but read it backwards.

  • Or, put a poem up on the screen and have us translate it,

  • only problem is the poem would be

  • in a language that none of us spoke.

  • Or we would read poems with a pen in our hand,

  • and write down every emotion,

  • every creative instinct or impulse

  • that the words created.

  • Well, now no one's reading with a pen in their hand,

  • they're not watching with a pen in their hand either.

  • Everyone has a smartphone,

  • and what they're doing is remixing,

  • mashing up and then spitting back out

  • into social media, whatever they can consume,

  • as fast as they consume it.

  • This is what happened to us this year,

  • we found Maggie Champagne,

  • I hope you recognise her, some of you.

  • Maggie is an amazing New York actress

  • and she has a great talent: she can open a can of soda,

  • she can -- she has many talents,

  • she can chug the can of soda,

  • and then she can dance inappropriately in public,

  • like this.

  • I know, that's disturbing,

  • but what we were attempting to do

  • was to disturb that lofty intellectual battle ground

  • of soda marketing.

  • We were tempting to make you stop, look up,

  • and go, "Is that for real?"

  • So reminds you, does it not, of T.S. Eliot

  • in "The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock", of course.

  • "Do I dare disturb the universe?

  • In a minute there is time

  • for decisions and revisions,

  • which a minute will reverse."

  • Now, of course, T.S. Eliot is not, as you may think,

  • rolling over in his grave that I'm up here from MTV,

  • on the TED stage,

  • and I'm using "The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock"

  • to eliminate the success

  • of a social marketing campaign for a soda.

  • T.S. Eliot would agree,

  • "in a minute there is time for decisions and revisions,

  • which a minute will reverse."

  • Well, a minute after we introduced Maggie

  • and her crazy inappropriate dancing to the world,

  • this is what the world, a minute later,

  • began giving us back:

  • (Video)

  • T.S. Eliot would agree,

  • the world moves forward by creative minds using things

  • in ways far beyond our intention.

  • Think about it, it happens to all of us every day:

  • you have an idea and you share it with someone,

  • someone has an idea and they share it with you,

  • you share it with other people

  • it gets bounced around and garbled

  • and what rises to the top, somehow,

  • is an idea that was better than your original concept.

  • That's not a happy accident, that's a magical consequence.

  • There is this poem I love by Wallace Stevens,

  • "Tea at the Palaz of Hoon",

  • and it's about how who we are informs

  • how we see everything.

  • Here is how the poem ends:

  • "I was the world in which I walked, and what I saw

  • Or heard or felt came not but from myself;

  • And there I found myself more truly and more strange."

  • I love that idea,

  • that by discovering the strangeness in ourself

  • we can find the truth.

  • The first step in speaking the truth

  • is to embrace our own messy imperfect genius,

  • and the second step is to embrace

  • the messy imperfect geniuses all around us.

  • What if, in work, in life, we could somehow

  • break free and let go of the need to be understood?

  • And instead, seek to be misunderstood

  • by creative minds,

  • and if that doesn't make perfect sense,

  • here in this room filled with

  • brilliant original minds, there you are.

  • Good, thank you!

  • (Applause)

The best thing we can hope for is not to be understood

字幕と単語

ワンタップで英和辞典検索 単語をクリックすると、意味が表示されます

B1 中級

TEDx】誤解の詩。ロス・マーティンがTEDxEastで (【TEDx】The poetry of misunderstanding: Ross Martin at TEDxEast)

  • 167 11
    阿多賓 に公開 2021 年 01 月 14 日
動画の中の単語