Placeholder Image

字幕表 動画を再生する

  • The Ninth of the Ten Commandments is "You shall not give false witness against your neighbor."

  • This means two things: "Do not lie when testifying in court."

  • And, "Do not lie." Period.

  • Remember, in order for an action to be prohibited or demanded in the Ten Commandments

  • it has to be fundamental to making civilization. As important as donkey riding might have been

  • when the Ten Commandments were given, the Ten Commandments contains no commandment to

  • ride your donkey responsibly. A society can survive bad donkey drivers.

  • But it cannot survive contempt for truth -- whether inside or outside a courtroom. If people testify

  • falsely in a courtroom, there can be no justice. And without even the hope of justice,

  • there can be no civilization.

  • The Hebrew Bible was so adamant on this subject that the punishment imposed on a witness who

  • gave false testimony was the same as the punishment that would have been meted out to the accused

  • had the false testimony been believed. In the case of a crime that would be punishable

  • by death, therefore, the false witness was liable to be put to death.

  • But the commandment is clearly concerned with truth generally, not only in a courtroom.

  • Both the great twelfth century Jewish commentator, Ibn Ezra, and one of the most influential

  • biblical scholars of the 20th century, Brevard Childs of Yale University, agreed that the

  • commandment was about truth-telling generally. As Childs pointed out, if the Ten Commandments

  • were solely concerned with truth and falsehood in a courtroom,

  • it would have added words such as "in court."

  • There are many important values in society, but truth is probably the most important.

  • Goodness and compassion may be the most important values in the micro, or personal, realm.

  • But in the macro, or societal, realm, truth is even more important than compassion or kindness.

  • Virtually all the great societal evils, such as African slavery, Nazism and Communism,

  • have been based on lies.

  • There were slavetraders, Nazis and Communists who were compassionate in their personal lives,

  • but all of them told, and most of them believed, some great lie that enabled them to participate

  • in a great evil. Black slavery was made possible in large measure by the lie that blacks were

  • innately inferior to whites. The Holocaust would have been impossible without tens of

  • millions of people believing the lie that Jews were inherently inferior to so-called Aryans.

  • And Communist totalitarianism was entirely based on lies. That's why the Soviet Union's

  • Communist Party newspaper was named Pravda, the Russian word for "Truth"

  • -- because the Party, not objective reality, was the source of truth.

  • There is only so much evil that can be done by individual sadists and sociopaths.

  • In order to murder millions, vast numbers of otherwise normal, even decent, people must believe lies.

  • Mass evil is committed not because a vast number of people seek to be cruel,

  • but because they are fed lies that convince them that what is evil is actually good.

  • However, one big obstacle to truth-telling is that believers in causes, including good causes,

  • that don't place truth as a central value, will be very tempted to lie on behalf of their cause.

  • There are many examples. In the 1980's, to promote the cause of the homeless,

  • the leading activist on their behalf, claimed that there were 2 to 3 million homeless in the United States.

  • Years later he admitted on national television that he had to come up with a number

  • and made that one up. The real number was between 250,000 and 350,000.

  • Similarly, groups in the fight against cancer were caught greatly exaggerating the number

  • of women who get breast cancer each year. Why? In order to frighten more women into

  • getting mammograms. Again, lying on behalf of a good cause. Why is lying on behalf of

  • good causes destructive? Because if we don't know what's true, how and where do we know

  • how to properly allocate society's limited resources?

  • And in the worst cases, it distorts society's priorities, and therefore does great harm.

  • The Ten Commandments is there to warn all of us that, with very few exceptions,

  • such as the immediate saving of innocent life, no cause is more important than truth-telling.

  • The Ten Commandments is the greatest list of instructions ever devised for creating a good society.

  • But such a society cannot be created or maintained if it is not based on truth.

  • I'm Dennis Prager.

The Ninth of the Ten Commandments is "You shall not give false witness against your neighbor."

字幕と単語

ワンタップで英和辞典検索 単語をクリックすると、意味が表示されます

B1 中級

9.9.偽りの目撃者を出してはいけない (9. Do Not Bear False Witness)

  • 66 5
    周杰 に公開 2021 年 01 月 14 日
動画の中の単語