Placeholder Image

字幕表 動画を再生する

  • - Every generation loves to complain

  • about the generation coming along,

  • but at the same time, there's a very sharp change

  • with kids who were born in 1995 and afterwards-

  • surprisingly sharp.

  • Beginning with kids born in 1995,

  • they spend a lot less time going out with friends.

  • They don't get a driver's license as often.

  • They don't drink as much.

  • They don't go out on dates.

  • They don't work for money as much.

  • What are they doing?

  • They're spending a lot more time sitting

  • on their beds with their devices interacting that way.

  • These are the first kids who got social media when

  • they were 13, roughly.

  • They were subjected to much more anti-bullying content

  • in their schools,

  • much more adult supervision.

  • They were raised in the years after 9/11.

  • They were given much less recess and free play.

  • With No Child Left Behind,

  • there was much more testing pushed down into earlier grades.

  • So in a lot of ways,

  • Gen Z has been denied the independence,

  • the independent play that previous generations got.

  • Gen Z has been raised with what's called 'moral dependency.'

  • There's always been an adult there for them to go to,

  • and so we don't know if this is for sure the reason,

  • but they seem to have more difficulty

  • working out problems on their own.

  • When we protect children from unpleasantness,

  • from conflicts, from insults, from teasing, from exclusion,

  • we are setting them up to be weak,

  • to be more easily damaged, to be more easily discouraged.

  • In the 1990s, as the crime rate was plummeting,

  • as American life was getting safer and safer,

  • Americans freaked out and thought that if they

  • take their eyes off their children,

  • the children will be abducted.

  • The fear was stoked by cable TV in the 1980s;

  • there were a few high-profile abductions.

  • - 'Last year, 50,000 children disappeared.

  • Many of them from nice, safe neighborhoods.'

  • - 'It's okay.

  • Come on, hop in.'

  • - 'Talk to your children

  • about not talking to strangers, and do it today.'

  • - But it's not until the 1990s

  • that we really start locking kids up and saying,

  • "You cannot be outside until you're 14 or 15."

  • Lenore Skenazy, who wrote the book, "Free Range Kids."

  • She became famous as "America's worst mom"

  • because in 2009, she let her 9-year-old son

  • ride the New York City subway.

  • Not only did he survive, he was thrilled.

  • He felt he'd learned something.

  • He felt he could go out into the world.

  • We took this essential period of childhood

  • from about 8 to 12, when kids throughout history

  • have practiced independence, have gotten into adventures,

  • have made rafts and floated down the Mississippi River-

  • we took that period and said,

  • "You don't get to practice independence,"

  • until it's too late, until that period is over.

  • Now, a couple years before you go to college,

  • "Now you can go outside. Oh, okay, go off to college."

  • And a lot of 'em are not ready.

  • They're just not used to being independent.

  • When they get to college, they need more help.

  • They're asking adults for more help.

  • Protect me from this.

  • Punish him for saying that.

  • Protect me from that book.

  • Students are thinking in terms of safety and danger.

  • Students say, by their own admission, they are more fragile.

  • They use a language of fragility, weakness,

  • trauma, triggering.

  • They see triggers all over the world.

  • What are triggers?

  • Triggers are cases where you take a part

  • of your nervous system and you say,

  • "If someone says that word,

  • they can control my nervous system

  • and make me afraid and anxious."

  • That's a terrible idea.

  • We should not be teaching our kids to to see the world

  • as being full of triggers.

  • We should teach them to live in a world

  • that is physically quite safe,

  • but full of offensive statements and ideas,

  • especially on the internet.

  • The bottom line is that if we want to raise a generation

  • of kids who can deal with diversity of all kinds,

  • who can go out into a world that's physically actually

  • quite safe but yet full of offensive, offensive content,

  • we need to get our educational practices in line

  • with some very basic, important psychological principles.

  • They are:

  • We are all prone to motivated reasoning

  • and the confirmation bias,

  • and we're all prone to tribalism,

  • and black-and-white thinking.

  • We need to be educating kids

  • so that they do less of this stuff.

  • Always trust your feelings:

  • It may sound wise, it may sound romantic.

  • But wise people around the world have noticed

  • that we don't react to the world as it actually is,

  • we react to the constructions, the perceptions.

  • Epictetus said,

  • "It is not things themselves that disturb us

  • but our interpretations of things."

  • All of us have had experiences with these.

  • One thing I like to think about is Homer Simpson saying:

  • 'Shut up, brain or I'll stab you with a Q-tip!'

  • - Our brains do this.

  • Our brains go on and on, and we're like,

  • "Stop it, stop it, stop it!"

  • What we've begun seeing on campus is

  • that students are encouraged to follow their feelings.

  • If they feel offended by something,

  • then they have been attacked.

  • They're supposed to not question those feelings.

  • But part of wisdom is the ability to say,

  • "Now, wait a second.

  • Are there other ways to look at this?"

  • These are crucial skills for critical thinking.

  • These are crucial skills for mental health.

  • And we need to be teaching young people

  • at all stages to question their first interpretations,

  • look for evidence,

  • and improve the way they interpret the world.

  • CBT is just a way of teaching people skills

  • to do exactly that,

  • to question their feelings, to look for evidence.

  • So in CBT, you learn the names of these distortions,

  • about 15 or so distortions.

  • You can guess what they mean:

  • Catastrophizing, black-and-white thinking,

  • labeling, mind reading.

  • Aaron Beck, a psychiatrist in the 1960s,

  • noticed that depressed and anxious people have a way

  • of constructing these beliefs that,

  • "I'm bad. The future is bad.

  • My future- the world is a bad place,"

  • and they're mutually reinforcing.

  • And this is the way the world feels to them.

  • And if you can improve their thinking

  • and break up those beliefs,

  • they're released from the depression.

  • Cognitive behavioral therapy is not more effective

  • than several other treatments.

  • There are-most treatments are about equally effective-

  • but it's so easy to learn!

  • Other techniques like meditation work, but they're harder;

  • most people drop off.

  • So CBT is easy, really well-tested,

  • has a huge impact on a variety of mental illnesses,

  • especially those related to depression and anxiety.

  • We think every college student, and heck,

  • every high school student should be taught

  • these basic skills,

  • given how high the rates of anxiety

  • and depression are today.

  • 'Life is a battle between good people and evil people.'

  • If you think about it for a moment, who are we?

  • What is our species?

  • We evolved in small-scale societies that

  • were locked in struggle with other small-scale societies.

  • Human nature is really, really finely tailored

  • for intergroup conflict, for tribal warfare.

  • This is the way our ancestors lived for a long time.

  • Now that we've transcended it, we're so desperate for it.

  • We've invented team sports, fraternities,

  • we love these sorts of competitions-

  • our brains are made for it.

  • Now, it can be fun or it can get dark,

  • and it can lead to racism, all kinds of-

  • all kinds of forms of bigotry.

  • And on some college campuses and in some high schools,

  • we see forms of education,

  • forms of training that teach students

  • to make more and more distinctions,

  • to see more and more binary dimensions between people

  • where the people who are high are bad,

  • the people who are low are good.

  • When we talk about identity politics,

  • which is a controversial topic,

  • we start by saying,

  • "Of course, you need identity politics."

  • Identity politics is not a bad thing automatically.

  • Politics can be based on any distinction.

  • It can be based on any group interest.

  • So, for gay students or Black students

  • or women who organize, that's identity politics;

  • that's perfectly legitimate.

  • The question is: How are they organizing?

  • What's the overarching framework?

  • And we've seen two versions of it in American history:

  • You can do it the way most

  • of the civil rights leaders did it,

  • Martin Luther King, in particular,

  • where you draw a larger circle around the group,

  • you emphasize what we have in common, and then you say,

  • "Some of our brothers and sisters

  • are being denied equal access,

  • equal opportunity, or equal dignity."

  • That works.

  • That has worked historically in much tougher times

  • and zones, and that works and will work on college campuses.

  • The other way you do it,

  • which is growing on college campuses,

  • is 'common enemy identity politics.'

  • It's based on the Bedouin notion:

  • 'Me against my brother,

  • me and my brother against our cousin,

  • me, my brother, and cousin against the stranger.'

  • It's a very general principle of social psychology.

  • If you try to unite people, "Let's all unite against them.

  • They're the bad people.

  • They're the cause of the problems.

  • Let's all stick together."

  • That's a really dangerous thing to do

  • in a multiethnic society.

  • Especially in a university, where we're actually

  • all trying to work together to solve the problem.

  • If we're creating multiethnic environments on campuses,

  • and in most of our organizations

  • we're struggling to increase diversity,

  • what you should obviously be doing is turning

  • down the tribal sentiments;

  • is emphasizing what we have in common.

  • Identity politics done with a common humanity frame,

  • is a good thing, and is likely to work.

  • Identity politics done by uniting everybody

  • against the people with power and privilege,

  • one race versus another race,

  • one gender versus another gender-

  • this is madness.

  • This is a really bad idea if you're trying

  • to emphasize an increased diversity and inclusion.

  • We call that common enemy identity politics.

  • The more we encourage people to see the people

  • around them as good versus evil,

  • the harder it's gonna be to create an an inclusive,

  • diverse environment.

  • - Thank you, and very well said.

  • Jonathan, thank you so much for your time.

  • - My pleasure.

  • - Get smarter, faster with videos

  • from the world's biggest thinkers.

  • And to learn even more from the world's biggest thinkers,

  • get Big Think+ for your business.

- Every generation loves to complain

字幕と単語

ワンタップで英和辞典検索 単語をクリックすると、意味が表示されます

B1 中級

Why modern America creates fragile children | Jonathan Haidt(Why modern America creates fragile children | Jonathan Haidt)

  • 19 2
    林宜悉 に公開 2023 年 04 月 05 日
動画の中の単語