ButthehighcourttojudgesofthehighcourtofdecidedthatthefullbenchshouldconsiderGeorgePillscasewhereheisseekingtochallengetheVictorianCourtofAppeal, rulingthatHedgeupheldhisconvictionby a juryinFebruarythisyear.
Nowthere's noexplanationbytheHighCourtjudgestoday, buttakeusthroughwhatisknownaboutthatapplicationbyGeorgePillsLegalteamfor a hearing.
Well, weknowabouttheargumentsbecausebothlegalteamsfiledextensivepaperdocumentsin a headoffthisapplicationthismorning, andtheybasicallyoutlinedthebattlegroundasbeingGeorgepills.
LawyerswanttosupportJusticeWeinberg's justiceMarkWeinberg's dissentingviewintheCourtofAppeal, wherehefoundthatthejuryresultwasunreasonableandthattherewas a prospectofwhilehewasquite.
Hequestionedtheevidencegivenbythecomplainantwth e othertwojudgesthroughallofthatout, and I heldthejuryfinding.
Andso, inpreviouscoverageoffthedefense's case, itsaidthatitwasgoingtoberelyingontwoproposedgroundsforappealthatfocusonthemajorityofdeceivingtodismisspulsecasesyoujustmentioned, but I'd liketogointothosein a bitmoredetailwithyou.
Sothe E quotedthedefenseinthesepapersissayingthemajorityerredbyfindingthattheirbeliefinthecomplainantrequiredtheapplicanttoestablishthattheoffendingwasimpossible.
It's veryunusualfortheHighCourttosayyesto a caseonthepapers, althoughoccasionallyitdoeslike a dudetodayon.
ButyoufindmanyMaurcasesthatgoto a specialleaveapplicationhearing.
Manymoreofthosedogetthrough, althoughquite a fewofthemarerejectedaswell.
Butifthehighcourt's willingtohearsomeoneargueoutwhytheyshouldhave a hearing, theymuchmoreinclinedtosayWethinkthere's a prospectof a goodcasehereandyes, ohdear, haveanyideaaboutthosepercentagesofthenumberofcases?
Canyoupointto a casepreviously, wheretherehasbeenanappealtothehighcourt, theHighKickHighCourthasdecidedtohearthatappealandit's beingsuccessful.
I mean, I'm notquitesurewhatthepercentageofsuccessfulappealstothecourt, butthat's quiteoftencasesdosucceed.
I thinkthetheonesthat I enjoythemost, there's onlybeenoneofJason's beinghere, otheroneswheresomeonehasrepresentedthemselves.
Butyouknow, there's sometimesofthehighcourt.
Onething I willsaythatthehighcourt, though, iswhenitdoesrule.
Itgives a decisiveandclearrulingbecauseitwantstoclarifythelaw.
Inmostcasessooften I'llbepreparedforsomecomplicatedresponseoffsomecomplicatedjudgment, and I'llfindthathavejustlaidsomethingoutverysimplysothateveryonecanunderstandit.
Sowhatevertheydowiththiscase, I thinkthat's that's probablywhatwe'rehittingforeitherway.