字幕表 動画を再生する 英語字幕をプリント I HAVE COMPILED A HUNDRED OR SO COMMON THESIS DEFENSE QUESTIONS WHICH WE WILL LOOK AT LATER ON ALL THESE QUESTIONS IN FACT ALMOST ALL THESIS DEFENSE QUESTIONS CAN BE PUT INTO THREE MAIN CATEGORIES LET'S GO THROUGH THEM TOGETHER SO THE FIRST CATEGORY OF COMMON THESIS DEFENSE QUESTIONS ARE THOSE SEEKING INFORMATION WHICH IS ACTUALLY ALREADY IN THE THESIS LET'S LOOK AT SOME EXAMPLES CAN YOU SUMMARIZE YOUR KEY FINDINGS IN JUST A FEW SENTENCES WHAT ARE THE KEY RESEARCHERS AND AUTHORS IN THIS RESEARCH AREA WHAT ARE THE MAIN ON-GOING DEBATES OR ISSUES IN THIS RESEARCH AREA WHAT IS THE SIGNIFICANCE OF YOUR CHOSEN TOPIC WHY DID YOU CHOOSE THIS TOPIC WHY DID YOU USE THE RESEARCH METHODOLOGY THAT YOU USED WHAT SAMPLING PROCEDURE DID YOU USE WHY DID YOU ARRIVE AT THIS SIMPLE SIZE WHY DID YOU INCLUDE THESE VARIABLES IN YOUR REGRESSION ANALYSIS HOW DO YOUR FINDINGS COMPARE TO OTHER STUDIES IN THE FIELD SO THESE ARE ALL EXAMPLES OF QUESTIONS ASKING FOR INFORMATION WHICH IS ALREADY IN THE THESIS OR THE DISSERTATION IF I WROTE MY THESIS PROPERLY AND AS LONG AS I CAN REMEMBER WHAT I WROTE THEN THESE QUESTIONS SHOULD BE RELATIVELY EASY TO ANSWER CAN I SUMMARIZE MY KEY FINDINGS IN A FEW SENTENCES SURE BECAUSE I'VE ALREADY SUMMARIZED MY KEY FINDINGS IN THE ABSTRACT OR IN THE EXECUTIVE SUMMARY THE KEY RESEARCHERS AND AUTHORS IN THIS AREA WELL THEY'RE ALREADY COVERED IN THE LIT REVIEW CHAPTER AND PROBABLY IN THE DISCUSSION CHAPTER ONGOING DEBATES ALREADY TALKED ABOUT IN MY LIT REVIEW AND IN MY DISCUSSION WHY DID I CHOOSE THIS TOPIC AND THE SIGNIFICANCE OF THIS TOPIC ARE ALREADY COVERED IN THE INTRO SAMPLE SIZE AND SAMPLING PROCEDURES ARE ALREADY DESCRIBED AND JUSTIFIED IN MY METHODOLOGY CHAPTER HOW MY FINDINGS COMPARED TO OTHER STUDIES ARE CAREFULLY DISCUSSED IN THE DISCUSSION CHAPTER SO THE ANSWERS TO THESE QUESTIONS ARE SIMPLY IN THE THESIS AS LONG AS MY THESIS IS PROPERLY WRITTEN AND AS LONG AS I CAN REMEMBER WHAT IS IN MY THESIS I CAN ADDRESS THESE QUESTIONS NO PROBLEM NOW IN MY OBSERVATION AND IN MY EXPERIENCE THESE QUESTIONS QUESTIONS ASKING FOR INFORMATION THAT IS ACTUALLY IN THE THESIS ARE MORE COMMON IN BACHELOR AND MASTER LEVEL THESIS DEFENSES AND THEY ARE LESS COMMON IN PHD DEFENSES AND THIS IS PROBABLY BECAUSE THESE QUESTIONS ARE RELATIVELY EASY TO ASK AND ANSWER ANOTHER POTENTIAL REASON MIGHT BE THAT THESE QUESTIONS ARE ASKED TO CHECK WHETHER THE STUDENT PERFORMED THE RESEARCH AND WROTE THE THESES THEMSELVES AND BECAUSE GHOST WRITING IS MORE OF A POTENTIAL CONCERN FOR BACHELOR THESES AND MASTER DISEASES THESE QUESTIONS ARE ASKED A BIT MORE IN BACHELOR AND MASTER LEVEL DEFENSES GHOST WRITING IS LESS OF A PROBLEM FOR PHD DISSERTATIONS SO TO ME THAT THESE QUESTIONS ARE NOT VERY FREQUENTLY ASKED IN PHD DEFENSES THE SECOND MAIN CATEGORY OF COMMON THESIS DEFENSE QUESTIONS ARE WHAT I CALL REFLECTIVE HYPOTHETICALS SO THESE QUESTIONS ARE CERTAINLY RELATED TO THE CONTENT OF THE THESIS BUT THEY ARE NOT DIRECTLY OR SPECIFICALLY FOCUSED ON THE ACTUAL SUBSTANCE OF WHAT IS ACTUALLY IN THE THESIS PER SE LET'S LOOK AT SOME EXAMPLES OF THESE REFLECTIVE HYPOTHETICALS IF YOU WERE TO PERFORM THIS RESEARCH STUDY ALL OVER AGAIN WHAT WOULD YOU DO DIFFERENTLY IF YOU COULD CHOOSE A DIFFERENT RESEARCH METHODOLOGICAL APPROACH TO INVESTIGATE YOUR RESEARCH QUESTION WHICH RESEARCH METHODOLOGY WOULD YOU USE AND WHY INSTEAD OF THIS HAD YOU DONE THAT WHAT DO YOU THINK WOULD BE DIFFERENT IN YOUR FINDINGS IF YOU WERE AN ASSESSOR OF THIS RESEARCH STUDY HOW WOULD YOU GRADE THIS WORK WHAT WOULD YOU CONSIDER TO BE THE MOST PROBLEMATIC ISSUE CONCERNING THIS STUDY SO THESE REFLECTIVE HYPOTHETICAL QUESTIONS CAN BE A LITTLE BIT MORE DIFFICULT TO PREPARE BECAUSE YOU DON'T KNOW WHICH DIRECTION THESE HYPOTHETICALS WOULD GO AND BECAUSE THESE QUESTIONS ARE NOT ABOUT ACTUAL THINGS THAT ARE IN THE THESIS I CAN'T SIMPLY TRY TO MEMORIZE EVERYTHING THAT I WROTE AND THEN BE ABLE TO ADDRESS THESE QUESTIONS WHICH MEANS THIS SECOND CATEGORY OF THESIS DEFENSE QUESTIONS CAN BE A LITTLE BIT CHALLENGING TO ANSWER BUT THE THING ABOUT THESE QUESTIONS IS THAT IF THEY ARE PROPERLY ADDRESSED AND ANSWERED THEY COULD ACTUALLY LEAD TO VERY INTERESTING DISCUSSIONS IN THE DEFENSE SO IF YOU ANSWER THESE QUESTIONS WELL IT CAN REALLY MAKE THE DEFENSE MUCH MORE INTERESTING AND ENJOYABLE AND IF YOU ANSWER THESE QUESTIONS PROPERLY IT CAN ADD COLORS TO THE DEFENSE AND HELP IMPRESS YOUR PROFESSORS AND THE FINAL AND THIRD CATEGORY OF COMMON THESIS DEFENSE QUESTIONS WHAT MANY WOULD CONSIDER AS A DIFFICULT TYPE OF QUESTIONS WOULD BE CHALLENGING AND ACCUSATORIAL QUESTIONS SO THESE QUESTIONS ARE ASKED BY THE PROFESSORS TO POINT OUT SOMETHING THAT THEY BELIEVE WAS NOT CORRECT THEY MAY BE POINTING OUT THINGS WHICH THEY VIEW AS INCORRECTLY DONE OR THEY MIGHT BE POINTING ON WHAT THEY PERCEIVE TO BE IMPORTANT EMISSIONS SOMETHING THAT SHOULD BE IN THE THESIS SOMETHING THAT SHOULD BE ADDRESSED BY THE THESIS BUT WASN'T LET'S TAKE A LOOK AT SOME EXAMPLES THE STUDY DONE BY AUTHOR X DEMONSTRATED Y WHICH CLEARLY ILLUSTRATES THAT YOUR STUDY FAILED IN Z AND YET YOU MADE NO MENTION OF THIS IN YOUR LIT REVIEW NOR IN YOUR DISCUSSION HOW DO YOU JUSTIFY THIS SERIOUS OMISSION LET ME POINT OUT TO YOU THAT THE THEORY THAT YOU USED TO COME CAPITALIZE YOUR MODEL OR THIS PARTICULAR SCALE WHICH YOU USED TO MEASURE THIS VARIABLE IS NOW CONSIDERED OUTDATED OBSOLETE OR UNRELIABLE BASED ON RECENT RESEARCH FINDINGS OF SO AND SO THIS SERIOUSLY UNDERMINES THE VALUE OF YOUR RESEARCH YOUR RESPONSE PLEASE SO THESE TWO QUESTIONS ARE ACTUALLY BOTH QUITE ACCUSATORIAL ACCUSING YOU OF HAVING DONE SOMETHING INCORRECTLY AND NOW LET'S TAKE A LOOK AT A COUPLE OF EXAMPLES WHICH ARE MORE OF A CHALLENGING NATURE I'D LIKE YOU TO TALK ABOUT WHY YOU CHOSE TO PERFORM THIS STUDY IN ORGANIZATION A INSTEAD OF ORGANIZATION B WHEN THE TOPIC APPEARS TO HAVE MORE SIGNIFICANCE FOR ORGANIZATION B OR ANOTHER EXAMPLE IN YOUR PRACTICAL IMPLICATIONS YOU SUGGEST THAT ORGANIZATIONS SHOULD DO X BECAUSE THAT WOULD AID ORGANIZATIONAL PERFORMANCE AND PRODUCTIVITY I'D LIKE TO CHALLENGE YOU TO GIVE MORE DETAILS AS TO HOW ORGANIZATIONS CAN ACTUALLY IMPLEMENT THIS SO THESE TWO QUESTIONS ARE LESS OF AN ACCUSATION BUT THEY ARE CHALLENGING THE STUDENT TO COME UP WITH MORE INFORMATION AND MORE EXPLANATION ABOUT SOMETHING THAT THEY WROTE IN THE THESIS AND THESE CHALLENGING ACCUSATORIAL QUESTIONS DEPENDING ON HOW THEY'RE PHRASED CAN BE ACTUALLY QUITE DIFFICULT TO ANSWER DURING THE DEFENSE IMAGINE THE CONTEXT AND THE SETTING OF A THESIS DEFENSE ESPECIALLY IF WE'RE TALKING ABOUT A THESIS DEFENSE AT A REPUTABLE UNIVERSITY WHERE THINGS ARE DONE VERY SERIOUSLY AND VERY FORMALLY A LEARNED PROFESSOR THROWS AT YOU A CRITICAL AND ACCUSATORIAL QUESTION AND ASKS YOU TO RESPOND ON THE SPOT WITHOUT THE OPPORTUNITY TO CONSULT ADDITIONAL LITERATURE WITHOUT THE OPPORTUNITY TO SPEAK WITH COLLEAGUES AND FELLOW RESEARCHERS WITHOUT THE OPPORTUNITY TO THINK ABOUT IT FOR A COUPLE OF HOURS ALL THAT MAKES THESE QUESTIONS DIFFICULT TO DEAL WITH I REMEMBER FOR MY OWN PHD DEFENSE I DID EVERYTHING I COULD TO PREPARE I HAD A LOT OF HELP FROM MY SUPERVISORS ADVISERS COLLEAGUES AND FRIENDS BUT STILL DURING THE DEFENSE THERE WERE QUESTIONS THAT I FOUND TO BE VERY DIFFICULT AND THOSE DIFFICULT QUESTIONS WERE THESE CHALLENGING AND ACCUSATORIAL QUESTIONS WHEN I WAS ASKED ABOUT SOMETHING WHICH WAS IN THE THESIS I COULD ANSWER VERY WELL BECAUSE I KNEW MY THESIS VERY WELL WHEN I WAS GIVEN A REFLECTIVE HYPOTHETICAL QUESTION I COULD STILL IMPROVISE AND WING IT AND TALK ABOUT STUFF BUT WHEN A PROFESSOR WHOM I RESPECTED GREATLY WHOSE WORK I CITED EXTENSIVELY IN MY OWN THESIS ASKED ME SOMETHING WHICH WAS VERY CHALLENGING AN ACCUSATORIAL POINTING OUT SOMETHING THAT THEY BELIEVE I DID WRONG WELL WAS DIFFICULT TO RESPOND TO WELL RIGHT THERE ON THE SPOT DURING THE DEFENSE BUT YOU SHOULD BE HAPPY TO KNOW DESPITE ALL THAT I PASSED MY DEFENSE WITH NO PROBLEM YOU SHOULD BE HAPPY TO KNOW THAT THAT IS JUST PART OF THE GAME BECAUSE THE FACT OF THE MATTER IS NO MATTER HOW WELL-PREPARED WE ARE CHANCES ARE THERE WILL ALWAYS BE QUESTIONS THAT WE FIND TO BE DIFFICULT OR EVEN IMPOSSIBLE TO ANSWER WELL DURING THE DEFENSE SO DON'T BE AFRAID OF THAT NOW IF YOU WANT TO KNOW HOW TO DEAL WITH THESE DIFFICULT QUESTIONS PLEASE CHECK OUT MY OTHER VIDEO TOP 10 TIPS FOR SUCCESSFUL DEFENSE AS USUAL LET ME END THE VIDEO WITH A FEW QUESTIONS DO YOU AGREE OR DISAGREE WITH MY TYPOLOGY OF COMMON THESIS DEFENSE QUESTIONS WHAT STRATEGIES WOULD YOU USE TO TACKLE EACH OF THE THREE CATEGORIES OF QUESTIONS WHAT SMART IDEAS DO YOU HAVE TO DEAL WITH THOSE TRICKY CHALLENGING ACCUSATORIAL QUESTIONS HOW HAVE YOU EXPERIENCED THESIS DEFENSES YOURSELF PLEASE LEAVE YOUR THOUGHTS AND COMMENTS DOWN BELOW AND IF YOUR COMMENT IS A GOOD ONE THEN PEOPLE WILL LIKE IT AND UPVOTE IT THEN EVERYBODY WILL SEE IT SO LEAVE A COMMENT ALRIGHT THANK YOU FOR WATCHING THIS RR VIDEO PLEASE LIKE AND SUBSCRIBE AND I'LL SEE YOU NEXT TIME
B1 中級 米 100 Thesis Defense Questions in 3 Categories 13 0 zz に公開 2024 年 04 月 15 日 シェア シェア 保存 報告 動画の中の単語