字幕表 動画を再生する
-
BARACK OBAMA: The U.S has the most durable economy in the world.
-
HILLARY CLINTON: I don't think President Obama gets the credit he deserves for digging us
-
out of the ditch that the republicans dropped us into.
-
DONALD TRUMP: We have other countries basically sucking away our money, sucking away our jobs.
-
BERNIE SANDERS: Anyone in this country who works 40 hours a week should not live in poverty.
-
IF you want a job in Elkhart County, you can find a job.
-
Its a good place to live for people who need a job who are not college-educated.
-
People tend to live paycheck to paycheck. The foodstamps that we get are not enough
-
to feed a family.
-
Most of our society thinks they deserve something. The Government tends to give too much to people
-
who don't want to work. I think we're more divided than we've ever been and the people
-
running for office now--who in the world are you going to vote for?
-
ANNOUNCER: This is a PBS NEWSHOUR special -- Questions for President Obama.
-
Now, from the Lerner Theatre in Elkhart, Indiana, PBS NewsHour co-anchor, Gwen Ifill.
-
GWEN IFILL: Good evening.
-
And welcome to Elkhart, Indiana, as we sit down with President Obama and the residents
-
of this community to discuss their concerns, look back on his time in office and assess
-
the feverish campaign to succeed him.
-
This marks the president's fifth visit to the once and again RV capital of the world
-
-- a small city where the unemployment rate hit 19.6 percent his first year in office
-
and now has dropped to about 4 percent.
-
But this White House isn't getting any credit for that turnaround. Residents here voted
-
for Ted Cruz in this year's primaries and Mitt Romney by two to one in 2012. Even when
-
President Obama won Indiana in 2008, just as the economy was crashing, Elkhart went
-
with John McCain.
-
So what gives?
-
We've asked some of the people who live here to join us on the stage of the beautiful Lerner
-
Theatre here downtown for an intimate conversation.
-
But first, the president of the United States, Barack Obama.
-
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: Hi, Gwen.
-
(APPLAUSE)
-
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: Thank you.
-
(APPLAUSE)
-
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: Thank you.
-
(APPLAUSE)
-
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: How are you?
-
GWEN IFILL: Hi, Mr. President.
-
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: It's good to see you.
-
GWEN IFILL: Thank you.
-
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: Hello.
-
(APPLAUSE)
-
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: Thank you.
-
(APPLAUSE)
-
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: Thank you, guys.
-
GWEN IFILL: Our residents have been waiting faithfully, patiently and eagerly to see you
-
today.
-
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: Well, I'm eager to see them.
-
And this is a beautiful theatre.
-
GWEN IFILL: It is beautiful.
-
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: Which got converted. Congratulations on a wonderful venue.
-
IFILL: Some of them voted for you, some of them didn't. We'll be talking about that...
-
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: Well, that's what we’d expect.
-
GWEN IFILL: -- in a moment.
-
But I first want to ask by talking to you a little bit about this campaign.
-
What do you think it means when you hear the words “let's make America great again”?
-
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: I think America is pretty great. And, you know, it's interesting,
-
I do a lot of commencement speeches this time of year. In fact, tomorrow, I'm going to be
-
going to the Air Force Academy to deliver a commencement for the second time there.
-
And I always remind young people that despite all the challenges that we face right now,
-
if you had the choice to be born in -- in any one period of time in -- in our history,
-
and you didn't know ahead of time whether you were going to be rich or poor, black or
-
white, male or female, you know, you just had to guess on what moment do you have a
-
best chance of succeeding, it actually would be now.
-
That America is the strongest country on Earth. Its economy is the most durable on Earth.
-
You know, we are a -- a country that has incredible diversity, people are striving, working hard,
-
creating businesses. We've got the best universities in the world, the best scientists.
-
You know, so we've got -- we've got some challenges and we've just come through a very rough stretch
-
as a consequence of the financial crisis, but overall, not only are we recovered from
-
the crisis that we had, but we're well positioned to do extraordinarily well going forward as
-
long as we make some good decisions.
-
GWEN IFILL: And yet, many people, including probably some folks in this room...
-
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: Yes.
-
GWEN IFILL: -- think the deficits have gone up and the jobless rate has gone up. And,
-
in fact, that their lives have not improved.
-
How -- in fact, we have your nominee for the -- the presumptive nominee for the Republican
-
Party saying, Donald Trump, saying this -- America is a third world nation.
-
How do you persuade -- or I suppose, how does your likely Democratic successor, possible,
-
persuade anybody that's not true?
-
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: Well, it's important you said my successor, because Michelle would
-
be very upset if she thought I was running again.
-
Look, you just look at the evidence here in Elkhart. As you mentioned in the introduction,
-
when I took office, this was the first city I came to. And unemployment about a month
-
after I took office, a month and a half after I took office, was almost 20 percent. One
-
out of 10 people were behind on their mortgage or in foreclosure.
-
Today, the unemployment rate is around 4 percent. It's only about one in 30 people who are behind
-
on their mortgage. The RV industry, which is, uh, central to Elkhart, is on track to
-
break records in terms of sales. And so that doesn't mean that folks aren't struggling
-
in some circumstances. And one of the things that I've emphasized is that there are some
-
long-term trends in the economy that we have to tackle in terms of wages not going up as
-
fast as they used to, some big costs, like college costs or health care costs that are
-
still a challenge, people still worrying about retirement.
-
And so we're going to have to make sure that we make some good decisions going forward.
-
But the notion that somehow America is in decline is just not borne out by the facts.
-
That...
-
GWEN IFILL: But it resonates. It resonates among a lot of...
-
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: Well...
-
GWEN IFILL: -- aggrieved people who are voting in big numbers for Donald Trump.
-
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: Well, look, -- I think that what it is also -- always been true in
-
American politics is that when we've gone through a tough time -- and we went through
-
the worst financial crisis of our lifetimes. I'm looking around and I -- I think it's safe
-
to say that it's been the worst in -- in the lifetimes or memories of most people here.
-
Then you feel nervous. People lost homes. People lost savings. People were worried about
-
whether or not they could make ends meet.
-
And so we're -- even though we've recovered, people feel like the ground under their feet
-
isn't quite as solid. And in those circumstances, a lot of times it's easy for somebody to come
-
up and say you know what, if we deport all the immigrants and build a wall or if we cut
-
off trade with China, or if we do X or Y or Z, that there's some simple answer and suddenly
-
everything is going to feel secure. And...
-
GWEN IFILL: Why don't -- why don't you mention Donald Trump by name?
-
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: You know, he seems to do a good job mentioning his own name,
-
so...
-
(LAUGHTER)
-
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: -- I figure -- you know...
-
(LAUGHTER)
-
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: -- I'll let him do his advertising for him.
-
GWEN IFILL: Do you consider at all that any of the support for him is backlash against
-
you personally?
-
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: Well, here's one thing I would say -- and I just spoke about this
-
at the local high school. I think Trump is a more colorful character than some of the
-
other Republican elected officials, but a lot of the story that he's telling is entirely
-
consistent with what folks have been saying about me or the general story they've been
-
telling about the economy for the last seven and a half, the last 10, the last 20, the
-
last 30 years. And you can -- you can actually describe the story fairly concisely, right?
-
The -- the basic story they tell is that the problems that the middle class working families
-
are experiencing has to do with a big bloated government that taxes the heck out of people
-
and then gives that money to undeserving folks, welfare cheats or, you know, the 47 percent
-
who are takers or, you know, whatever phrase they use, that businesses are being strangled
-
by over-regulation, that, you know, Obamacare has killed jobs.
-
And the fact of the matter is when you look at it, the government, as a proportion of
-
our overall economy, is actually smaller now under my presidency than it was under Ronald
-
Reagan...
-
GWEN IFILL: Let me read you something...
-
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: : -- I have...
-
GWEN IFILL: -- that Bill Clinton said, though.
-
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: But -- but let me -- let me finish, Gwen.
-
GWEN IFILL: OK.
-
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: We have fewer federal employees today.
-
GWEN IFILL: Um-hmm.
-
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: The -- the health care costs since I signed Obamacare have actually
-
gone up slower than they were before I signed it. Twenty million more people have health
-
insurance.
-
So the arguments they're making just are not borne out by the facts. But what is true is
-
that if people are feeling secure -- feeling insecure and they're offered a simple reason
-
for how they can feel more secure, people are going to be tempted by it, particularly
-
if they're hearing that same story over and over again.
-
GWEN IFILL: Perception. So Bill Clinton said, "Millions and millions and millions of people
-
look at that pretty picture of America you painted," which you just described, "and they
-
cannot find themselves in it to save their lives."
-
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: The pretty picture that...
-
GWEN IFILL: The pretty picture of all the things that have gone well. Why is there a
-
disconnect between -- that he's describing here?
-
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: Well, look, here's what has changed in the economy over the last
-
20 to 30 years. Right after World War II, America was ascendant. It was dominant around
-
the world because Europe was blown up. Japan was digging itself out of the rubble. China
-
was still a backwater. Eastern Europe was behind the Iron Curtain.
-
There wasn't much competition. We were the only folks who were seriously making cars
-
and trucks and appliances and you name it.
-
We had strong unionization, which meant that workers had leverage so that they could get
-
a good share of a growing pie. And people saw each year and each generation their standards
-
of living going up pretty rapidly.
-
And what started happening is you started seeing foreign competition. Unions started
-
getting busted, so workers had less leverage, which meant their wages didn't go up quite
-
as fast. You started seeing the end of defined benefit pension plans. In terms of health
-
care programs, if you had health care on your job, suddenly you were paying a lot of deductibles
-
and premiums.
-
College costs started going up because the public university system, which used to be
-
generously funded by state governments so that tuition was low, suddenly state governments
-
were spending more money on prisons than they were on universities, which meant tuition
-
went up.
-
You add all those things together, and people then start feeling more stressed.
-
Now, the answer to that is how do we get wages up; how do we make sure that you can save
-
for retirement; how can you make sure that your kid can afford to get a higher education
-
to compete for the jobs of the future. And the question then is what is actually going
-
to get that done?
-
To me, if we raise the minimum wage; if we make it easier not harder for people to unionize;
-
if we negotiate trade deals that raise labor standards and environmental standards in other
-
countries, instead of letting them sell here and we can't sell there; if we make sure that
-
we're rebuilding our roads and our bridges and our infrastructure to put a bunch of folks
-
in hard-hats back to work; if we make Social Security stronger rather than cutting it.
-
If we do those things, then we are going to see wages go up, labor markets tighten, and
-
we will relieve a lot of the stress that people feel. But if you look at the arguments that
-
are being made by the Republicans and the actions that have been taken by those members
-
of Congress, it's hard to see how cutting taxes for the wealthiest Americans, deregulating
-
Wall Street again, is somehow going to benefit middle class families.
-
GWEN IFILL: But let's turn to the audience and see what they think. We're going to open
-
this conversation up. I have a lot more questions, but they do, too. And we're going to be right
-
back in just a moment with that.
-
(BREAK) GWEN IFILL: So Mr. President, we are back
-
with a few questions for you from our invited audience here. They are anxious to get started
-
and so am I.
-
You're a small businessman here in Elkhart.
-
BILL KERCHER, Farmer: Yes, I am.
-
GWEN IFILL: What's your name?
-
BILL KERCHER: Bill Kercher.
-
GWEN IFILL: What's your question for the president?
-
BILL KERCHER: Mr. President, I am a fifth-generation fruit and vegetable grower here in Elkhart
-
County. And over the last six years, we've seen a dramatic increase in the number of
-
regulations that touch all aspects of our business, from the Food Safety Modernization
-
Act to Obamacare and many others.
-
Now, large farms are able to comply with these regulations more easily, and small family
-
farms we've seen actually exiting the industry. At what point are we overregulated, if not
-
now? And how can we encourage younger growers to either stay or enter an industry when the
-
barriers to entry are higher than ever?
-
Thank you.
-
PRESIDENT BARACK OBAMA: Well, it's a great question. And first of all, my administration's
-
policy has been to encourage family farming, rather than big agribusiness, because not
-
only is that sort of a model of farming that built this country, but as Michelle will tell
-
you, it actually produces food that's better for you, as she reminds me constantly.
-
So, you know, we want you to succeed. Now, if you look at the trend lines in terms of
-
small family farms, the problem generally has been actually farms getting bought up
-
by larger agricultural operations. It's been you guys not always getting good prices for
-
the products that you put together.
-
I don't doubt that some elements of the regulations I put in place have probably put a burden
-
on you. So let's take health care for example. It may be that previously you weren't -- you
-
didn't think you were able to provide health insurance for your employees. The problem
-
is that if they're not getting health insurance through you, then that means that they're
-
relying on the emergency room. And they're relying on, you know, taxpayers like everybody
-
else to cover those costs if they get in an accident or if they get sick.
-
And so it has always been our view that if we can put something together where people
-
can buy health insurance through a pool, it's subsidized if they're not making enough money
-
to pay for their own health insurance, that that overall is going to be a more efficient
-
way to do it and in fact health care inflation, the rate at which healthcare costs have gone
-
up, for small businesses as well as large businesses, has been significantly slower
-
since I passed the law than it was beforehand.