字幕表 動画を再生する
-
On June 26, 2020, the US House of Representatives voted to do something it had never done before.
-
It passed a bill to create the 51st state by giving the US capital, Washington, DC, statehood.
-
Members of the House of Representatives each represent between 500,000 and a million Americans.
-
DC's 700,000 residents are represented by this woman: Eleanor Holmes Norton.
-
But she couldn't vote on the statehood bill, because she's different from other members.
-
She can speak on the floor and introduce bills, but she can't actually vote.
-
Americans in territories like Puerto Rico and Guam
-
are also represented in Congress by “delegates” who can't vote.
-
But Americans in these places don't pay federal taxes to the US government.
-
DC residents do.
-
In fact, in DC, the average person pays more in federal taxes than in any state.
-
And they're not happy about it.
-
It's why DC's license plates say “Taxation without representation.”
-
President Trump has promised to block Washington, DC, from becoming a state.
-
So that House vote was mostly symbolic.
-
But Washington, DC's residents are clear on what they want.
-
So will DC ever actually become a state?
-
And should it?
-
In the US, the federal government is not supposed to be based in a state.
-
The Constitution says it should be in a neutral federal district —
-
what, today, is called the District of Columbia.
-
But since the founding of the country, the district has grown into a major city.
-
"For most of its existence as a city,
-
the District has been under the control of the United States Congress."
-
Starting in the 1960s, Congress made some concessions to DC's calls for representation.
-
It granted them electoral college votes for presidential elections,
-
a non-voting member in Congress,
-
and finally, the right to elect their own local government.
-
But because Congress still completely controls their budget,
-
they often undermine DC's local government --
-
which is another major reason DC residents want statehood.
-
"Like most cities in the United States, it is a progressive city.
-
And so its laws conflict, in some measure, with that of conservative Republicans."
-
That's understating it a little.
-
In the 2016 election, Trump only got a whopping 4% of the vote in DC.
-
Congress has kept DC from using their local tax dollars on things like abortion services,
-
or needle-exchange programs to reduce HIV/AIDS.
-
They've tried to undercut DC's gun laws and same-sex marriage benefits.
-
And they stopped the city from legalizing marijuana.
-
"There are issues in the country, that are very controversial,
-
that Republicans can't do anything about. So they use the District as a prop."
-
Holmes Norton's plan would turn most of the District of Columbia
-
into a new state, called the Douglass Commonwealth.
-
There would still be a federal district around the actual government buildings,
-
but the remaining 66 square miles of neighborhoods would become the newest, smallest state.
-
But it would still have a larger population than two states,
-
and would be about the same size as four others.
-
So, what's the holdup?
-
Well, representatives from other states have lots of reasons.
-
"The Founding Fathers did not intend for Washington, DC, to be a state."
-
"Washington, DC, is a city, not a state."
-
"There is no manufacturing. There is no mining or logging."
-
But it's not a coincidence that every representative speaking out against statehood here is Republican.
-
Statehood would give DC, and most likely the Democratic Party,
-
one more vote in the House of Representatives, and two more votes in the Senate.
-
Which means the actual obstacle to statehood, is politics.
-
"Indeed, always, statehood is a political question."
-
In the decades after the US was founded, new states were regularly added,
-
and without much issue -- until 1818, when Missouri wanted to become a new state.
-
At that time, power in Congress was evenly balanced between states that allowed slavery,
-
and states that didn't.
-
Missouri, which would become a slave state, would tip that balance —
-
which representatives of the free states didn't want.
-
So Congress came up with a compromise:
-
Missouri would be added at the same time as Maine, a free state.
-
A pair, to keep the political balance.
-
After that, states were mostly added in pairs.
-
Arkansas, a slave state, with Michigan, a free state;
-
Florida, a slave state, with Iowa, a free state;
-
Texas, a slave state, with Wisconsin, a free state.
-
And that system has also been used to keep the balance between the political parties,
-
most recently in 1959, with the addition of Hawaii, which leaned Republican at the time,
-
and Alaska, which leaned Democratic.
-
Right now, Democrats control one house of Congress,
-
but Republicans control the other one, as well as the presidency.
-
And as long as that's the case, DC is unlikely to become a state on its own.
-
"It would certainly be easier if there were some ready jurisdiction
-
to be made a state that was a Republican jurisdiction."
-
The last time the House voted on DC statehood was in 1993,
-
when Democrats had an even bigger majority than they do today.
-
The bill still failed, with more than 100 Democrats voting no.
-
2020 is turning out to be different.
-
"Coronavirus begins to take a toll on the US economy."
-
"More than 6 million Americans filed jobless claims."
-
In March, as millions lost their jobs, Congress passed a coronavirus relief bill,
-
giving each state at least a billion dollars.
-
But DC, which is usually treated like a state in most congressional funding,
-
was instead treated as a US territory, and got less than half that.
-
"Being treated like a territory is shocking. It's infuriating."
-
In June, as protests against police violence spread across the country,
-
the National Guard patrolled parts of the city.
-
That kind of occupation would be illegal in every state. But not in DC.
-
"There shouldn't be troops from other states in Washington, DC.
-
The last several days demonstrate that our fight for statehood
-
is also about our right to autonomy."
-
"It's time for statehood to come to Washington, DC."
-
"We've seen in very painful, and frankly violent terms,
-
what the lack of statehood can bring to the residents of the District of Columbia."
-
Right now, the people in charge of the federal government oppose DC statehood.
-
But it only takes one election to change that.
-
"My own grandfather became one of the first African Americans in the DC fire department.
-
His father, Richard Holmes, was a runaway slave from Virginia.
-
He walked to freedom. But he didn't walk to equality.
-
So I figure I'm picking up where he left off.
-
He got us to freedom, he got the Holmes family to freedom;
-
now I've got to get the Holmes family, and all my constituents, to equality."