字幕表 動画を再生する
-
When Jane Austen published Pride and Prejudice anonymously on January 29, 1813,
-
who could've imagined that over 200 years later,
-
it would be one of the most cherished novels of English literature?
-
Pride and Prejudice has inspired countless film and TV adaptations,
-
spin-offs, sequels, and modern retellings,
-
so in this video, we're going to take a look at four English-language
-
on-screen adaptations and how they compare to the novel.
-
This is Pride and Prejudice By the Book.
-
"It's no use. I've struggled in vain.
-
I must tell you how much I admire and love you."
-
The first Hollywood feature film adaptation of Pride and Prejudice
-
was released in July of 1940.
-
Shown in theaters ahead of America's involvement in the Second World War,
-
the film featured a romanticized view of “Old England”
-
while minimizing the novel's emphasis on class distinctions.
-
If you're wondering why Elizabeth Bennet looks more like Scarlett O'Hara here,
-
it's because the filmmakers made significant changes to the story
-
to further appeal to their audience.
-
This included moving the time period some 40 years ahead,
-
allowing them to showcase the costumes inspired by Victorian era fashions.
-
And with the incredible success of Gone with the Wind,
-
which the studio had released just months before,
-
it was determined that these extravagant dresses would look better on screen.
-
"Look, Mama! Lady Lucas's carriage!"
-
"Pass them, Batings! Pass them!”
-
New scenes were invented for the film and major plot points radically revised
-
to incorporate elements of the screwball comedies that were so popular in the 1930s.
-
One of the first major plot changes takes place at the Assembly ball,
-
which combines several events from the novel.
-
Here, Elizabeth meets Wickham and dances with him before Darcy and the Bingleys even arrive.
-
This is a huge change from the sequence of events in the novel
-
and it affects the dynamics between the characters.
-
"Yes, she looks tolerable enough.
-
But I'm in no humor tonight to be of consequence to the middle classes at play."
-
Because the film also combines later events from the book,
-
Darcy asks Elizabeth to dance just minutes after insulting her.
-
Not surprisingly, she refuses.
-
"I'm afraid that the honor of standing up with you, Mr. Darcy, is more than I can bear."
-
However, she does accept Wickham's invitation to dance almost immediately afterwards.
-
This sassy response would have been considered highly improper during Austen's time
-
and never appeared in the book.
-
Naturally, though, adapting a 300-page book for a two-hour movie
-
will call for combining and condensing major plot points.
-
The challenge is being able to capture the essence of the novel
-
and maintain the overall narrative arc.
-
Some characters don't make it into this film at all
-
and neither does Elizabeth's visit to Pemberley.
-
Although the screenplay keeps some of the more famous dialogue,
-
it also, in some ways, fundamentally changes the characters.
-
For instance, we see a much more personable and charming Darcy, as portrayed by Laurence Olivier,
-
while Greer Garson's Elizabeth is more strong-willed and sarcastic.
-
At the Netherfield ball turned garden party, the screenplay has Darcy rescue Elizabeth
-
from Mr. Collins by lying to him.
-
"Do you happen to know Miss Elizabeth Bennet?"
-
"I do, sir."
-
"Has she - has she passed this way, may I ask?"
-
"No, sir. She has not passed this spot."
-
Although entertaining, this exchange would have been uncharacteristic of the Darcy from the novel
-
who prides himself on his honesty and lack of pretense.
-
And later, we have Lady Catherine de Bourgh transformed into a matchmaker
-
who deliberately brings Darcy and Elizabeth together.
-
"What you need is a woman who will stand up to you.
-
I think you've found her."
-
In the end, the 1940 film definitely diverges from the novel
-
in favor of the studio's signature glitz and glamour,
-
but this fun adaptation features splendid costumes, witty banter,
-
and of course, the iconic love story.
-
"In vain have I struggled.
-
It will not do, my feelings will not be repressed.
-
You must allow me to tell you how ardently I admire and love you.”
-
This five-episode miniseries is the fifth BBC television adaptation of Pride and Prejudice.
-
The BBC's history with the novel stretches back to 1924,
-
when they broadcast an excerpt of Pride and Prejudice on radio for the first time.
-
Unlike the earlier studio-bound TV productions with fixed cameras,
-
the 1980 series utilized moving cameras, outdoor locations, and a musical score.
-
The screenplay established it as one of the most faithful versions of the novel
-
since it kept the majority of the original text and storylines.
-
However, there are a few notable changes,
-
including a more feminist interpretation of the plot and dialogue.
-
For instance, while the novel starts off with a conversation between Mr. and Mrs. Bennet,
-
Elizabeth's wittiness and Charlotte's pragmatism take center stage in the adaptation.
-
"A single man in possession of a good fortune coming to live at Netherfield."
-
"It is a truth universally acknowledged that such a man must be in want of a wife."
-
"Of course."
-
The screenplay especially gives attention to the female characters
-
and their character development, at the expense of the male characters.
-
"Even after twenty years, my mother still fails to understand him.
-
Her mind is less difficult to comprehend."
-
Because Jane Austen used the third person omniscient voice in Pride and Prejudice
-
to relate the characters' thoughts and feelings,
-
the screenwriter tries to incorporate this narration through dialogue,
-
as well as long, internal monologues.
-
As far as changes to the plot, there are just a few.
-
One example is the scene after Elizabeth learns of Lydia's elopement.
-
As soon as she finishes reading Jane's letter,
-
she apparently runs the distance of several miles to Pemberley,
-
bursting into Darcy's drawing room in search of her uncle.
-
In this case, Elizabeth is the one who seeks Darcy out, and not the other way around.
-
Overall, the 1980 production stays true to the book
-
and includes various scenes from the novel that are not found in other adaptations.
-
It is fairly consistent in using costumes based on fashions from the early 1800s,
-
and although it doesn't have the big-budget production values of later versions,
-
this entertaining adaptation does its best
-
to present an accurate portrayal of the characters of Pride and Prejudice.
-
“In vain I have struggled. It will not do.
-
My feelings will not be repressed.
-
You must allow me to tell you how ardently I admire and love you.”
-
In 1995, BBC collaborated with the A&E network to release the acclaimed six-episode adaptation
-
of Pride and Prejudice that would become a cultural phenomenon.
-
The miniseries is faithful to the original text
-
in that it covers most of the major plot points and retains much of the dialogue,
-
while also bringing the Regency era setting and characters to life.
-
What especially sets the award-winning series apart from earlier adaptations
-
is the introduction of the male perspective on events in the novel, right from the opening scene.
-
This series also takes time to focus specifically on Darcy,
-
showing scenes of him riding, fencing,
-
tracking down Lydia and Wickham through the streets of London,
-
and of course, the iconic lake scene.
-
"Mr. Darcy!"
-
Colin Firth's performance of Darcy as a sympathetic hero struggling with his feelings for Elizabeth
-
captured the attention of millions around the world.
-
And Jennifer Ehle's expressiveness subtly conveyed Elizabeth's intelligence and exuberance.
-
The supporting actors were also given the chance to add further depth to their characters.
-
"I long for a ball, and so does Denny."
-
"And Sanderson. Don't you Sanderson?"
-
"I do indeed.
-
Most passionately."
-
Scenes of everyday life and other period details help to immerse the viewer into their story,
-
showing characters going about their everyday routines, whether they were getting dressed,
-
getting ready for bed, or interacting with servants.
-
The attention to historical detail also ensured that the characters looked and acted realistically
-
according to the time period.
-
The costume designer created clothing that was authentic, yet attractive for the modern era,
-
and would complement the actors' as well as their characters' personalities.
-
To this day, the 1995 version of Pride and Prejudice
-
is considered to be the gold standard of book adaptations
-
for being able to capture the spirit of the novel and also balance its satire and romance.
-
Not only did it renew interest in Jane Austen's life and literary works,
-
it also inspired many to create their own Austenian love stories.
-
I've fought against my better judgment, my family's expectation,
-
the inferiority of your birth, my rank and circumstance, all these things,
-
but I'm willing to put them aside and ask you to end my agony."
-
"I don't understand."
-
"I love you."
-
65 years after the release of the first feature film adaptation of Pride and Prejudice,
-
Keira Knightley and Matthew Macfadyen step into the lead roles.
-
Marketed to a younger audience, the film features a more creative interpretation of the text,
-
emphasizing the romance and drama.
-
With limited screen time, the director and screenwriter faced the challenge of condensing the story
-
as well as the added pressure of matching up to the popular BBC version.
-
To differentiate itself visually, the film is supposed to be set in the 1790s,
-
around the time that Jane Austen finished her first draft of Pride and Prejudice,
-
originally titled First Impressions.
-
The film uses various ways to emphasize the relative poverty of the Bennets
-
compared to Darcy and his companions.
-
The livestock and laundry on clothesline around the Bennets' home portray a greater contrast
-
between the social standings of the protagonists.
-
The natural world is also used to reflect and intensify Elizabeth and Darcy's emotions.
-
A number of minor characters and plot points from the novel were cut
-
in order to emphasize the main love story.
-
Even some of the major characters in the novel,
-
who are vital to the development and resolution of the conflict,
-
end up with smaller roles in the film.
-
We also see a change in the dynamics within the Bennet family
-
as well as in Elizabeth's friendships with Jane and Charlotte.
-
"So don't judge me, Lizzy, don't you dare judge me!"
-
Similar to what happened with the 1940 film, the costumes and hairstyles were adjusted
-
to appeal to new audiences and also to complement the story.
-
Elizabeth's appearance often shows her tomboyish nature,
-
whereas Caroline Bingley is always dressed in the height of fashion.
-
In contrast, Mrs. Bennet and Lady Catherine are shown in fashions of the past
-
to reflect what they would've worn in their younger years.
-
And finally, Mr. Darcy's clothing is used to symbolize his character change
-
as he falls in love with Elizabeth.
-
To sum up, the dialogue, behavior, and costumes in the 2005 film all feature a contemporary twist,
-
giving viewers a glimpse into Georgian society through a modern lens.
-
"So what do you recommend, to encourage affection?"
-
"Dancing. Even if one's partner is barely tolerable."
-
In addition to the portrayal of a more feisty and rebellious Elizabeth,
-
the beautiful locations and thoughtful cinematography
-
bring the world of Pride and Prejudice to a new generation.
-
All of these adaptations of Pride and Prejudice
-
seek to tell the tale of self-discovery and true love.
-
The novel's themes of love and marriage, class and reputation, prejudice and pride,
-
continue to be relevant and relatable across cultures.
-
Although the four mentioned in this video are considered to be straight adaptations
-
of the novel, we can see how the story has been adapted for each audience and era.
-
The influence of Pride and Prejudice continues to be evident in movies, television, and books,
-
resulting in a story that has been retold in so many different ways.
-
Where will writers take Jane Austen's classic novel next?
-
We'll just have to wait and see.
-
Which Pride and Prejudice adaptation is your favorite?
-
Let us know in the comments below and subscribe to catch our next video!
-
Thanks for watching!